Policy Text
WINDERMERE POLICE DEPARTMENT
GENERAL ORDER
This order consists of the following:
1. Purpose
2. Policy
3. Definitions
4. Procedures
1. Purpose
The purpose of this policy is to serve both management and the individual employee to
document the employee’s job performance to support standardized, fair , and impartial
personnel decisions; maintain and improve job performance; provide a medium for
perso nnel counseling and development; facilitate proper decisions regarding
probationary employees; provide an objective and fair means for measurement and
recognition of individual job performance within assignments , and identify training needs.
2. Policy
It shall be the policy of the Windermere Police Department to utilize and maintain a fair
and equitable performance evaluation system for all employees.
4. Procedures
A. Performance Evaluation Process
1. An effective performance evaluation process is an integral part of the
agency/member relationship. The problem maximizes member
effectiveness by clarifying expectations, recognizing accomplishments,
and establishing career development. Effective Date: October 27, 202 5 Rescinds
Amends 18.4 ( October 1 , 202 5) Number: 18.4
SUBJECT : Performance Evaluations
Print Date: 10/27/25
Distribution: All Personnel Review Month: October
18.4, Page 2
2. Agency sworn members are evaluated utilizing an Annual Performance
Review. These evaluations are designed to measure performance criteria.
All performance criteria must be evaluated. Evaluations are conducted
with a rating period of one year, beginning June 1st.
3. A member’s supervisor/manager must document the successful or
unsuccessful completion of the probationary period for newly hired sworn
personnel and newly promoted personnel .
4. The work performance of each sworn probationary member is evaluated
at least once during the probationary period, in writing, using job-related
measures and procedures. The FTO program evaluations and disciplinary
probation do not qualify for this requirement. This applies to all newly
hired or newly promoted sworn members. [12.06 ]
B. Purpose of Performance Evaluations [12.01(A )][12.03]
1. Serve management and the member in improving member performance
and thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and effectiveness of the
agency.
2. Provide a medium for ongoing feedback between the member and the
supervisor to improve performance, ide ntify training needs, and assist in
career development.
3. Facilitate accurate and timely evaluations.
4. Provide an objective and fair means for recognition and measurement of
member performance in accordance with prescribed guidelines (Appendix
A).
5. Assure the public that members are capable of performing their assigned
duties and responsibilities.
6. Ensure supervisors are evaluated on the quality and effectiveness of their
usage of the performance evaluation system.
7. May be used to support a member’s credentials for promotional
opportunities or special assignment transfers.
C. Supervisor/Evaluator Responsibilities
18.4, Page 3
1. The primary duties and responsibilities of the supervisor in the
administration of the performance evaluation process are to : [12.01( F)]
a. Ensure the process is conducted in an honest, fair, timely, and
impartial manner which is directed towards meeting agency
objectives.
b. Ensure members are qualified and capable of carrying out their
assigned duties and responsibilities.
c. Establish realistic performance expectations, measure and track
performance, and deliver ongoing feedback.
d. Ensure members have the necessary resources and training to
achieve desired results.
e. Establish and maintain member accountability in achieving
objectives through periodic performance feedback and action
plans.
f. Complete required agency training to administer the performance
evaluation process correctly .
2. Performance Evaluation Schedules:
a. All members shall be evaluated at least annually by their immediate
supervisor , with the rating period beginning June 1st. [12.01(D)]
b. Daily Observation Reports for field training officers must be
completed for members participating in a field training program.
When successful program comple tion is attained, monthly
observation reports must be completed until the probationary
period is complete. [12.06]
c. Promoted members shall be evaluated at the end of their
probationary period. The Deputy Chief shall document the overall
progress of th e supervisor in training at the end of Phase Two in a
written memorandum directed to the Chief of Police.
3. Performance Evaluation Preparation:
a. During the evaluation meeting, the supervisor , shall review each of
the following with the member:
18.4, Page 4
1. Tasks of the position are outlined in the official job
description. [12.04(A)]
2. Level of performance expected and defined objectives.
[12.04(B)]
3. Performance criteria. [12.04(C)]
b. The supervisor and member shall engage in ongoing feedback
throughout the evaluation period.
c. The supervisor shall maintain notes regarding periodic
performance discussions. Notes should include dates, times, and
events of a member’s performance during the evaluation period.
d. The supervisor shall provide written notification to all non-
probationary members whose performance is deemed to be
unsatisfactory. This notification must be given at least 90 days
before the end of the evaluation period. The notification is not an
evaluation; it is intended t o notify the member of their upcoming
performance evaluation and any areas needing improvement.
e. If completion of the 90 -day notification is applicable, the
notification must be signed by the member and supervisor. A copy
of the notification