Policy Text
Policy
301Santa Monica Police Department
Santa Monica Police Department Policy Manual
Copyright Lexipol, LLC 2024/04/18, All Rights Reserved.
Published with permission by Santa Monica Police
DepartmentReview Boards - 1Review Boards
301.1 GENERAL
At times, Department members are confronted with situations in which varying degrees of force
or actions are used to protect life and property, affect an arrest, or discharging firearms in the
performance of their duties. Department Members are also involved in incidents where their
actions cause great concern to the Department and general public.
The Santa Monica Police Department utilizes many different methods in our efforts to continually
improve ourselves and the systems we work within every day. However, there are times when
more formal, critical analysis of our operations is necessary. Therefore, in the interest of public
safety and the safety of Department Members, the Santa Monica Police Department shall review
critical incidents to ensure best practices are being utilized in policies, procedures, tactics, and
training.
301.2 INCIDENT REVIEW BOARD
301.2.1 PURPOSE AND SCOPE
The focus of the Incident Review Board (IRB) process is to identify areas for agency, unit,
or individual improvement. The goal is to consistently increase the Department's ability to
recommend necessary changes to policies, procedures, tactics, and training.
The review process conducted by the IRB shall be independent of any other review or investigation
by Internal Affairs, the Criminal Investigative Division, or any outside agency having jurisdiction
over the investigation or evaluation of an incident involving a Santa Monica Police Department
employee.
The IRB does not have the authority to recommend discipline. Before an incident can be referred
to the IRB, any personnel complaints should have already been initiated by the employee's
supervisor, Lieutenant or administrator. However, in the event the IRB finds a potential policy
violation that has not already been initiated, documented, or investigated, it shall be referred to
the Division Commander for further review.
The convening of a board may be tolled for an administrative investigation, criminal investigation
or by order of the Chief of Police.
Additionally, members who exhibited acts of bravery, courage, and/or exceptional performance
shall be discussed and recommendation for the appropriate Department commendation shall be
considered.
301.2.2 BOARD COMPOSITION
The Deputy Chief's Executive Officer will be the Incident Review Board Chairperson and ensure
that no members of the IRB have a conflict that would impact their objectivity or review of the
incident. The responsibility of the Chairperson may rotate at the discretion of the Deputy Chief. The
IRB composition shall consist of the following members:
Santa Monica Police Department
Santa Monica Police Department Policy Manual
Review Boards
Copyright Lexipol, LLC 2024/04/18, All Rights Reserved.
Published with permission by Santa Monica Police
DepartmentReview Boards - 2•The Deputy Chief's Executive Officer, or Deputy Chief's designee, will serve as the
Chairperson.
•Member of equal job classification
oIn a case involving a sworn member, the SMPOA shall appoint the Board
member of equal rank.
oIn a case involving a civilian member, the Board member shall be appointed by
the Chairperson.
•Union board member
oIn a case involving a sworn member, the SMPOA Board member will be
appointed by the SMPOA Board of Directors.
oIn a case involving a civilian member, a representative from the concerned
employee's labor union or association shall be appointed by the Chairperson.
•Subject Matter Expert, depending on the type of IRB convening
oPersons identified who exhibit an advanced level of expertise in performing and/
or explaining a specific duty assignment, task, or skill will be considered as,
"Subject Matter Experts."
oThis position will be appointed by the Chairperson.
•Personnel and Training Sergeant, or designee.
In a case involving a civilian member, an Incident Review Board shall consist of a member
of similar classification within the police department and a representative from the concerned
employee's labor union or association, both shall be appointed by the Chairperson.
For a more comprehensive and complete review of the incident, additional members and/ or
persons may be invited to attend by the Chairperson. For the purpose of the review, they shall be
referred to as "Attendees" and shall be able to provide recommendations and/or comments to the
Board, but they are non-voting members. Incident-specific members could include the following:
•Training Division Representative
•Special Weapons and Tactics team representative
•Range Master
•External law enforcement agency subject matter expert
•External non-law enforcement subject matter expert
301.2.3 RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD
The IRB is empowered to conduct an administrative review and inquiry into the circumstances
of an incident. Members will review the material, discuss the incident, and identify any areas for
improvement with specific proposals for addressing the issue if possible. Discussions shall focus
on policies, procedures, tactics, training, equipment, use of force, and updates to best practices.
Emphasis should be placed on identifying areas for improvement.
Santa Monica Police Department
Santa Monica Police Department Policy Manual
Review Boards
Copyright Lexipol, LLC 2024/04/18, All Rights Reserved.
Published with permission by Santa Monica Police
DepartmentReview Boards - 3Specific subjects for review and recommendation include, but are not limited to, the following:
•Training
•Equipment and technology
•Communications
•Decision-making
•Supervision
•Policy, laws, or other departmental directives
•Tactical deployment and teamwork
•Award or commendation consideration (IRB may nominate a member for an award or
commendation for further review by the awards committee)
•Any issues