Question 1

What did the Ninth Circuit decide in Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier?

Accepted Answer

Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.

Question 2

Is Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier still good law?

Accepted Answer

FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier in the current circuit citation data.

Question 3

When was Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier decided?

Accepted Answer

This case was decided on December 3, 1970.

Question 4

How do I cite Union Oil Company of California, a Corporation, and Fred L. Hartley v. David D. Minier, Phillips Petroleum Company, a Corporation, and Frank Davis v. David D. Minier, Texaco, Inc., a Corporation, and Wallace A. Avery v. David D. Minier, Crandall D. Jones and Humble Oil Refining Company, a Corporation v. David D. Minier?

Accepted Answer

Use the citation No. 294480 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.

Feature	FlawFinder	Westlaw	LexisNexis
Monthly price	$19 – $99	$133 – $646	$153 – $399
Contract	None	1–3 year min	1–6 year min
Hidden fees	$0, always	Up to $469/search	$25/mo + per-doc
FlawCheck citator	Included	KeyCite ($$$)	Shepard's ($$$)
Plain-English summary	Included	No	No
Cancel	One click	Termination fees	Account friction

Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Full legal research for $19/month