Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/State of California, Ex Rel. Bill Lockyer, Attorney General, Coral Power, LLC Duke Energy North America, LLC Duke Energy Trading and Marketing, LLC Transcanada Energy Ltd. City of Tacoma, Washington Portland General Electric Company Dynegy Power Marketing, Inc. El Segundo Power Llc, Long Beach Generation LLC Cabrillo Power I LLC Cabrillo Power II LLC Mirant Americas Energy Marketing Lp Mirant California, LLC Mirant Delta, LLC Mirant Potrero, LLC Public Service Company of New Mexico El Paso Merchant Energy Lp Bp Energy Co. Public Service Company of Colorado Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Arizona Public Service Co. Pacificorp Pacificorp Power Marketing, Inc. Strategic Energy Llc, Intervenors, Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc., Respondent-Intervenor, Aes Companies Reliant Energy Services, Inc. Enron Power Marketing, Inc. Enron Energy Services, Inc., Intervenors, Powerex Corp. Puget Sound Energy Avista Energy, Inc. Sempra Energy Trading Corp., Sempra Energy Solutions Sempra Energy Resources, Respondents-Intervenors, California Public Utilities Commission, Petitioner-Intervenor, Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Company, Intervenor v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Avista Corporation, Intervenor, Long Beach Generation Llc, Respondent-Intervenor
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 787780
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
State of California, Ex Rel. Bill Lockyer, Attorney General, Coral Power, LLC Duke Energy North America, LLC Duke Energy Trading and Marketing, LLC Transcanada Energy Ltd. City of Tacoma, Washington Portland General Electric Company Dynegy Power Marketing, Inc. El Segundo Power Llc, Long Beach Generation LLC Cabrillo Power I LLC Cabrillo Power II LLC Mirant Americas Energy Marketing Lp Mirant California, LLC Mirant Delta, LLC Mirant Potrero, LLC Public Service Company of New Mexico El Paso Merchant Energy Lp Bp Energy Co. Public Service Company of Colorado Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Arizona Public Service Co. Pacificorp Pacificorp Power Marketing, Inc. Strategic Energy Llc, Intervenors, Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc., Respondent-Intervenor, Aes Companies Reliant Energy Services, Inc. Enron Power Marketing, Inc. Enron Energy Services, Inc., Intervenors, Powerex Corp. Puget Sound Energy Avista Energy, Inc. Sempra Energy Trading Corp., Sempra Energy Solutions Sempra Energy Resources, Respondents-Intervenors, California Public Utilities Commission, Petitioner-Intervenor, Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Company, Intervenor v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Avista Corporation, Intervenor, Long Beach Generation Llc, Respondent-Intervenor
No. 787780 · Decided September 9, 2004
No. 787780·Ninth Circuit · 2004·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
September 9, 2004
Citation
No. 787780
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
State of California, Ex Rel. Bill Lockyer, Attorney General, Coral Power, LLC Duke Energy North America, LLC Duke Energy Trading and Marketing, LLC Transcanada Energy Ltd. City of Tacoma, Washington Portland General Electric Company Dynegy Power Marketing, Inc. El Segundo Power Llc, Long Beach Generation LLC Cabrillo Power I LLC Cabrillo Power II LLC Mirant Americas Energy Marketing Lp Mirant California, LLC Mirant Delta, LLC Mirant Potrero, LLC Public Service Company of New Mexico El Paso Merchant Energy Lp Bp Energy Co. Public Service Company of Colorado Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Arizona Public Service Co. Pacificorp Pacificorp Power Marketing, Inc. Strategic Energy Llc, Intervenors, Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc., Respondent-Intervenor, Aes Companies Reliant Energy Services, Inc. Enron Power Marketing, Inc. Enron Energy Services, Inc., Intervenors, Powerex Corp. Puget Sound Energy Avista Energy, Inc. Sempra Energy Trading Corp., Sempra Energy Solutions Sempra Energy Resources, Respondents-Intervenors, California Public Utilities Commission, Petitioner-Intervenor, Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Company, Intervenor v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Avista Corporation, Intervenor, Long Beach Generation Llc, Respondent-Intervenor is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for State of California, Ex Rel. Bill Lockyer, Attorney General, Coral Power, LLC Duke Energy North America, LLC Duke Energy Trading and Marketing, LLC Transcanada Energy Ltd. City of Tacoma, Washington Portland General Electric Company Dynegy Power Marketing, Inc. El Segundo Power Llc, Long Beach Generation LLC Cabrillo Power I LLC Cabrillo Power II LLC Mirant Americas Energy Marketing Lp Mirant California, LLC Mirant Delta, LLC Mirant Potrero, LLC Public Service Company of New Mexico El Paso Merchant Energy Lp Bp Energy Co. Public Service Company of Colorado Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Arizona Public Service Co. Pacificorp Pacificorp Power Marketing, Inc. Strategic Energy Llc, Intervenors, Morgan Stanley Capital Group, Inc., Respondent-Intervenor, Aes Companies Reliant Energy Services, Inc. Enron Power Marketing, Inc. Enron Energy Services, Inc., Intervenors, Powerex Corp. Puget Sound Energy Avista Energy, Inc. Sempra Energy Trading Corp., Sempra Energy Solutions Sempra Energy Resources, Respondents-Intervenors, California Public Utilities Commission, Petitioner-Intervenor, Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Company, Intervenor v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Avista Corporation, Intervenor, Long Beach Generation Llc, Respondent-Intervenor in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on September 9, 2004.
Use the citation No. 787780 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.