Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/Roy and Josie Fisher, Next of Kin of Elizabeth Fisher, Boyd and Elizabeth Lewis, Next of Kin of Elizabeth, Ellen, Warren, and Jeff Lewis Lloyd D. And Virginia Hall, Next of Kin of Kenneth and Lloyd D. Hall and George and Joyce Brown Hutton, Next of Kin of Mondre Hutton All on Behalf of Any Persons Similarly Situated, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number One Tucson School District Number One Board of Education and Its Individual Members, Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry and Thomas Lee, Superintendent of Tucson School District Number One, and Sidney L. Sutton, Sally J. Sutton, and Sidney L. Sutton and Sally J. Sutton as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sean Sutton John R. Centeno, Mary Katherine Centeno and John R. Centeno and Mary Katherine Centeno as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sandra Katherine Centeno and James Lee Centeno Librada G. Ruiz and Librada G. Ruiz as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Andres L. Ruiz Sidney Taize and Sidney Taize as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Jonathan Taize, Lisa Taize and Joshua Taize, Defendants-Intervenors-Appellants. Sidney L. Sutton, Individually and on Behalf of His Wife and Minor Children, and Maria Mendoza, Individually and on Behalf of Stephen Mendoza, a Minor Theresa Trujillo, Individually and on Behalf of Albert Trujillo, Joe Trujillo, and David Trujillo, Minors Alberto Sanchez, Individually and on Behalf of Jaime Sanchez, Ana Celis Sanchez, John Sanchez, Ernest Sanchez, George Sanchez, and Betty Sanchez, Minors and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and Julia O. Flores, Billie Gutierrez, Theresa Medina, Betty M. Granillo, Carol Cruz-Popkin, Barney Paul Popkin, Carmen P. Urrutia, Manuel Alvarado, Carolyn Hackworth, Gloria Hagler, Johnny Randolph-Kelly, Thelma B. Manriquez, Aldolfo A. Suarez, Nat Washington Ii, Ralph O. Gomez, Juan Brito, Marcia Almeda, Emilia Talamantez, Ellen Lee Esperanza Silva, Antonette Romo, Ronald Q. Huerta, and Lupe Montano, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number 1 the Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry, Individually and as Members, Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Thomas Lee, Individually and as Superintendent of Tucson School District Number 1
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 380200
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Roy and Josie Fisher, Next of Kin of Elizabeth Fisher, Boyd and Elizabeth Lewis, Next of Kin of Elizabeth, Ellen, Warren, and Jeff Lewis Lloyd D. And Virginia Hall, Next of Kin of Kenneth and Lloyd D. Hall and George and Joyce Brown Hutton, Next of Kin of Mondre Hutton All on Behalf of Any Persons Similarly Situated, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number One Tucson School District Number One Board of Education and Its Individual Members, Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry and Thomas Lee, Superintendent of Tucson School District Number One, and Sidney L. Sutton, Sally J. Sutton, and Sidney L. Sutton and Sally J. Sutton as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sean Sutton John R. Centeno, Mary Katherine Centeno and John R. Centeno and Mary Katherine Centeno as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sandra Katherine Centeno and James Lee Centeno Librada G. Ruiz and Librada G. Ruiz as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Andres L. Ruiz Sidney Taize and Sidney Taize as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Jonathan Taize, Lisa Taize and Joshua Taize, Defendants-Intervenors-Appellants. Sidney L. Sutton, Individually and on Behalf of His Wife and Minor Children, and Maria Mendoza, Individually and on Behalf of Stephen Mendoza, a Minor Theresa Trujillo, Individually and on Behalf of Albert Trujillo, Joe Trujillo, and David Trujillo, Minors Alberto Sanchez, Individually and on Behalf of Jaime Sanchez, Ana Celis Sanchez, John Sanchez, Ernest Sanchez, George Sanchez, and Betty Sanchez, Minors and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and Julia O. Flores, Billie Gutierrez, Theresa Medina, Betty M. Granillo, Carol Cruz-Popkin, Barney Paul Popkin, Carmen P. Urrutia, Manuel Alvarado, Carolyn Hackworth, Gloria Hagler, Johnny Randolph-Kelly, Thelma B. Manriquez, Aldolfo A. Suarez, Nat Washington Ii, Ralph O. Gomez, Juan Brito, Marcia Almeda, Emilia Talamantez, Ellen Lee Esperanza Silva, Antonette Romo, Ronald Q. Huerta, and Lupe Montano, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number 1 the Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry, Individually and as Members, Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Thomas Lee, Individually and as Superintendent of Tucson School District Number 1
No. 380200 · Decided June 27, 1980
No. 380200·Ninth Circuit · 1980·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
June 27, 1980
Citation
No. 380200
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Roy and Josie Fisher, Next of Kin of Elizabeth Fisher, Boyd and Elizabeth Lewis, Next of Kin of Elizabeth, Ellen, Warren, and Jeff Lewis Lloyd D. And Virginia Hall, Next of Kin of Kenneth and Lloyd D. Hall and George and Joyce Brown Hutton, Next of Kin of Mondre Hutton All on Behalf of Any Persons Similarly Situated, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number One Tucson School District Number One Board of Education and Its Individual Members, Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry and Thomas Lee, Superintendent of Tucson School District Number One, and Sidney L. Sutton, Sally J. Sutton, and Sidney L. Sutton and Sally J. Sutton as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sean Sutton John R. Centeno, Mary Katherine Centeno and John R. Centeno and Mary Katherine Centeno as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sandra Katherine Centeno and James Lee Centeno Librada G. Ruiz and Librada G. Ruiz as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Andres L. Ruiz Sidney Taize and Sidney Taize as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Jonathan Taize, Lisa Taize and Joshua Taize, Defendants-Intervenors-Appellants. Sidney L. Sutton, Individually and on Behalf of His Wife and Minor Children, and Maria Mendoza, Individually and on Behalf of Stephen Mendoza, a Minor Theresa Trujillo, Individually and on Behalf of Albert Trujillo, Joe Trujillo, and David Trujillo, Minors Alberto Sanchez, Individually and on Behalf of Jaime Sanchez, Ana Celis Sanchez, John Sanchez, Ernest Sanchez, George Sanchez, and Betty Sanchez, Minors and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and Julia O. Flores, Billie Gutierrez, Theresa Medina, Betty M. Granillo, Carol Cruz-Popkin, Barney Paul Popkin, Carmen P. Urrutia, Manuel Alvarado, Carolyn Hackworth, Gloria Hagler, Johnny Randolph-Kelly, Thelma B. Manriquez, Aldolfo A. Suarez, Nat Washington Ii, Ralph O. Gomez, Juan Brito, Marcia Almeda, Emilia Talamantez, Ellen Lee Esperanza Silva, Antonette Romo, Ronald Q. Huerta, and Lupe Montano, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number 1 the Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry, Individually and as Members, Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Thomas Lee, Individually and as Superintendent of Tucson School District Number 1 is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Roy and Josie Fisher, Next of Kin of Elizabeth Fisher, Boyd and Elizabeth Lewis, Next of Kin of Elizabeth, Ellen, Warren, and Jeff Lewis Lloyd D. And Virginia Hall, Next of Kin of Kenneth and Lloyd D. Hall and George and Joyce Brown Hutton, Next of Kin of Mondre Hutton All on Behalf of Any Persons Similarly Situated, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number One Tucson School District Number One Board of Education and Its Individual Members, Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry and Thomas Lee, Superintendent of Tucson School District Number One, and Sidney L. Sutton, Sally J. Sutton, and Sidney L. Sutton and Sally J. Sutton as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sean Sutton John R. Centeno, Mary Katherine Centeno and John R. Centeno and Mary Katherine Centeno as Parents, Natural Guardians and Next Friend of Sandra Katherine Centeno and James Lee Centeno Librada G. Ruiz and Librada G. Ruiz as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Andres L. Ruiz Sidney Taize and Sidney Taize as Parent, Natural Guardian and Next Friend of Jonathan Taize, Lisa Taize and Joshua Taize, Defendants-Intervenors-Appellants. Sidney L. Sutton, Individually and on Behalf of His Wife and Minor Children, and Maria Mendoza, Individually and on Behalf of Stephen Mendoza, a Minor Theresa Trujillo, Individually and on Behalf of Albert Trujillo, Joe Trujillo, and David Trujillo, Minors Alberto Sanchez, Individually and on Behalf of Jaime Sanchez, Ana Celis Sanchez, John Sanchez, Ernest Sanchez, George Sanchez, and Betty Sanchez, Minors and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and Julia O. Flores, Billie Gutierrez, Theresa Medina, Betty M. Granillo, Carol Cruz-Popkin, Barney Paul Popkin, Carmen P. Urrutia, Manuel Alvarado, Carolyn Hackworth, Gloria Hagler, Johnny Randolph-Kelly, Thelma B. Manriquez, Aldolfo A. Suarez, Nat Washington Ii, Ralph O. Gomez, Juan Brito, Marcia Almeda, Emilia Talamantez, Ellen Lee Esperanza Silva, Antonette Romo, Ronald Q. Huerta, and Lupe Montano, Plaintiffs-Objectors-Appellees, and United States of America, Plaintiff-Intervenor-Appellee v. Tucson School District Number 1 the Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Leba Wine, Soleng Tom, Mitchell Vavich, Helen Haffley, and Katie Dusenberry, Individually and as Members, Board of Education, Tucson School District Number 1 Thomas Lee, Individually and as Superintendent of Tucson School District Number 1 in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on June 27, 1980.
Use the citation No. 380200 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.