Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Minor, and as Personal Representative of Taylor McKenzie Sigman Deceased James Douglas Sigman a Minor Taylor McKenzie Sigman, Deceased, Planlaintiffs-Appelants v. United States of America, Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Woman v. United States of America, Hazel Roberts, Wife Harold Roberts, Husband v. United States of America, Marilyn Moe v. United States of America, Marlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melisa Moe, Minor, by and Through Her Guardian Ad Litem Kelly Moe, Minor, by and Through the Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones, on Her Own Behalf, and Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Minor, by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Eva Irene Walch, Plaintiff-Appelant v. United States of America, Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children v. United States of America, Ruth Gerken v. United States of America, Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children, Anthony Zuchetto and Janessa Zucchetto, United States of America, Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estae of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner v. United States of America, Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones v. United States of America, Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Pual McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Represtatvie of the Estae of Christian Franics McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child, Christian Francis Mc Carron, Deceased, Estate of v. United States of America, Heather Ford, a Single Woman, Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor v. United States of America, Ashely N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Aminor, and as Personal Arepresentative of Taylor McKenzie Asigman, Deceased James Douglas Asigman, a Minor Taylor Amckenzie Sigman, Deceased Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Awoman Hazel Roberts, Wife Aharold Roberts, Husband Pauline Brown Marilyn Moe Amarlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melissa Moe, Minor, by and Athrough Her Guardian Ad Litem Akelly Moe, Minor, by and Athrough the Guardian Ad Litem Aselma Jones, on Her Own Behalf Aand Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Aminor, by and Through His Aguardian Ad Litem Eva Irene Walch Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children Ruth Gerken Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estate of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem Selma Jones J. Arthur Zucchetto Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Paul McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Representative of the Estate of Christian Francis McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child Christian Francis McCarron Deceased, Estate of Heather Ford, a Single Woman Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor Ashley N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 768262
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Minor, and as Personal Representative of Taylor McKenzie Sigman Deceased James Douglas Sigman a Minor Taylor McKenzie Sigman, Deceased, Planlaintiffs-Appelants v. United States of America, Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Woman v. United States of America, Hazel Roberts, Wife Harold Roberts, Husband v. United States of America, Marilyn Moe v. United States of America, Marlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melisa Moe, Minor, by and Through Her Guardian Ad Litem Kelly Moe, Minor, by and Through the Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones, on Her Own Behalf, and Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Minor, by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Eva Irene Walch, Plaintiff-Appelant v. United States of America, Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children v. United States of America, Ruth Gerken v. United States of America, Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children, Anthony Zuchetto and Janessa Zucchetto, United States of America, Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estae of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner v. United States of America, Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones v. United States of America, Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Pual McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Represtatvie of the Estae of Christian Franics McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child, Christian Francis Mc Carron, Deceased, Estate of v. United States of America, Heather Ford, a Single Woman, Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor v. United States of America, Ashely N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Aminor, and as Personal Arepresentative of Taylor McKenzie Asigman, Deceased James Douglas Asigman, a Minor Taylor Amckenzie Sigman, Deceased Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Awoman Hazel Roberts, Wife Aharold Roberts, Husband Pauline Brown Marilyn Moe Amarlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melissa Moe, Minor, by and Athrough Her Guardian Ad Litem Akelly Moe, Minor, by and Athrough the Guardian Ad Litem Aselma Jones, on Her Own Behalf Aand Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Aminor, by and Through His Aguardian Ad Litem Eva Irene Walch Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children Ruth Gerken Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estate of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem Selma Jones J. Arthur Zucchetto Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Paul McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Representative of the Estate of Christian Francis McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child Christian Francis McCarron Deceased, Estate of Heather Ford, a Single Woman Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor Ashley N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States
No. 768262 · Decided March 29, 2000
No. 768262·Ninth Circuit · 2000·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
March 29, 2000
Citation
No. 768262
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Minor, and as Personal Representative of Taylor McKenzie Sigman Deceased James Douglas Sigman a Minor Taylor McKenzie Sigman, Deceased, Planlaintiffs-Appelants v. United States of America, Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Woman v. United States of America, Hazel Roberts, Wife Harold Roberts, Husband v. United States of America, Marilyn Moe v. United States of America, Marlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melisa Moe, Minor, by and Through Her Guardian Ad Litem Kelly Moe, Minor, by and Through the Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones, on Her Own Behalf, and Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Minor, by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Eva Irene Walch, Plaintiff-Appelant v. United States of America, Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children v. United States of America, Ruth Gerken v. United States of America, Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children, Anthony Zuchetto and Janessa Zucchetto, United States of America, Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estae of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner v. United States of America, Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones v. United States of America, Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Pual McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Represtatvie of the Estae of Christian Franics McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child, Christian Francis Mc Carron, Deceased, Estate of v. United States of America, Heather Ford, a Single Woman, Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor v. United States of America, Ashely N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Aminor, and as Personal Arepresentative of Taylor McKenzie Asigman, Deceased James Douglas Asigman, a Minor Taylor Amckenzie Sigman, Deceased Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Awoman Hazel Roberts, Wife Aharold Roberts, Husband Pauline Brown Marilyn Moe Amarlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melissa Moe, Minor, by and Athrough Her Guardian Ad Litem Akelly Moe, Minor, by and Athrough the Guardian Ad Litem Aselma Jones, on Her Own Behalf Aand Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Aminor, by and Through His Aguardian Ad Litem Eva Irene Walch Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children Ruth Gerken Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estate of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem Selma Jones J. Arthur Zucchetto Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Paul McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Representative of the Estate of Christian Francis McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child Christian Francis McCarron Deceased, Estate of Heather Ford, a Single Woman Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor Ashley N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Minor, and as Personal Representative of Taylor McKenzie Sigman Deceased James Douglas Sigman a Minor Taylor McKenzie Sigman, Deceased, Planlaintiffs-Appelants v. United States of America, Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Woman v. United States of America, Hazel Roberts, Wife Harold Roberts, Husband v. United States of America, Marilyn Moe v. United States of America, Marlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melisa Moe, Minor, by and Through Her Guardian Ad Litem Kelly Moe, Minor, by and Through the Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones, on Her Own Behalf, and Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Minor, by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Eva Irene Walch, Plaintiff-Appelant v. United States of America, Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children v. United States of America, Ruth Gerken v. United States of America, Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children, Anthony Zuchetto and Janessa Zucchetto, United States of America, Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estae of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner v. United States of America, Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Selma Jones v. United States of America, Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Pual McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Represtatvie of the Estae of Christian Franics McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child, Christian Francis Mc Carron, Deceased, Estate of v. United States of America, Heather Ford, a Single Woman, Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor v. United States of America, Ashely N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States of America, Michelle Renee Sigman, on Her Behalf and as Guardian Ad Litem for James Douglas Sigman, a Aminor, and as Personal Arepresentative of Taylor McKenzie Asigman, Deceased James Douglas Asigman, a Minor Taylor Amckenzie Sigman, Deceased Lorraine T. Murray, a Single Awoman Hazel Roberts, Wife Aharold Roberts, Husband Pauline Brown Marilyn Moe Amarlene Moe, on Her Own Behalf Melissa Moe, Minor, by and Athrough Her Guardian Ad Litem Akelly Moe, Minor, by and Athrough the Guardian Ad Litem Aselma Jones, on Her Own Behalf Aand Bryan Joseph (Bj) Hansen, a Aminor, by and Through His Aguardian Ad Litem Eva Irene Walch Tiffany Williams, Individually and on Behalf of Sean Williams and Hali Williams, Her Minor Children Ruth Gerken Sandee Wold, Individually and on Behalf of Her Minor Children Rande Lindner, as the Duly Appointed and Qualified Personal Representative of the Estate of Anita Louise Lindner, Deceased, for the Benefit of Rande Lindner, Anastasia L. Lindner, Richard L. Lindner, Robert M. Lindner and Candice M. Lindner Samuel Alton Spencer, a Minor by and Through His Guardian Ad Litem Selma Jones J. Arthur Zucchetto Gregory Paul McCarron Husband Gregory Paul McCarron on Behalf of Ryan William John McCarron His Minor Child as Personal Representative of the Estate of Christian Francis McCarron Deceased Echo Ann McCarron Wife Ryan William John McCarron a Minor Child Christian Francis McCarron Deceased, Estate of Heather Ford, a Single Woman Ledeana Kelley, Wife Shawn Kelley, Husband Rebecca Kelley, a Minor Ashley N. Williams, a Minor, by and Through Her Natural Father and Guardian Ad Litem, Sean Williams Sean Tyler Williams, Guardian Ad Litem v. United States in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on March 29, 2000.
Use the citation No. 768262 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.