McColgan v. Lineker

GILBERT, Circuit Judge. On January 22, on the trial of a suit of the appellees against the appellants herein, the latter interposed a defensive plea of res judicata. Argument was had on the plea on January 24, 1922. At the close of the argument certain comments upon the case were made by the trial judge, which were made the basis of an affidavit of personal bias and prejudice against the judge, and a motion that another judge be designated to try the case under the provisions of section 20 of the Judicial Code (Comp. St. § 987). But the affidavit and motion were not filed until March 16, 1922, 13 days after, the decision of the court upon the plea. On August 21, 1922, an order was made denying the motion for designation of another •judge. From that order the present appeal is taken, the appellants assigning error to the denial of their motion. No statutory provision is made for appeal from such an order. Nor is the order a final judgment from which appeal may be taken, within the grant of appellate .jurisdiction to the Circuit Courts of Appeals. In Crooker v. Knudsen, 232 Fed. 857 , 147 C. C. A. 52 , this court said : "The Circuit Courts of Appeals are given no right to review other than final judgments, except injunction orders, and no judgment is final which does not terminate the litigation between the parties on the merits of the case, or on some severable phase thereof.” In Ex parte Am. Steel Barrel Co., 230 U. S. 35, 45 , 33 Sup. Ct. 1007, 57 L. Ed. 1379 , Mr. Justice Lurton intimated that the order in *254 such a case might be excepted to and assigned as error, and taken advantage of when the case finally should come under the reviewing power of an appellate tribunal. The appeal is dismissed.