FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 673031
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration, in Re Lawrence B. Smith, Attorney for Rule 11 Sanctions, Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration

No. 673031 · Decided June 24, 1994
No. 673031 · Ninth Circuit · 1994 · FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
June 24, 1994
Citation
No. 673031
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
Frequently Asked Questions
Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration, in Re Lawrence B. Smith, Attorney for Rule 11 Sanctions, Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration, in Re Lawrence B. Smith, Attorney for Rule 11 Sanctions, Kenneth A. Bellows v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration J. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration E. Tazewell Ellett, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald H. Boberick, Former Regional Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Leland S. Edwards Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration, Dane T. Roundtree v. Samuel K. Skinner, Secretary, Department of Transportation James B. Busey Iv, Administrator, Federal Aviation Administration C. Dean McGrath Jr., Acting General Counsel, Department of Transportation Neil R. Eisner, Assistant General Counsel, Department of Transportation Kenneth P. Quinn, Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Gregory S. Walden, Former Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Daniel D. Campbell, General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John M. Stuhldreher, Former General Counsel, National Transportation Safety Board John H. Cassady, Deputy Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Donald P. Byrne, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Peter J. Lynch, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Mardi R. Thompson, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Karen R. Bury, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Joseph A. Conte, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Harry S. Gold, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration John C. Curry, Assistant Chief Counsel, Federal Aviation Administration Delinda L. Wall, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Donald E. Borey, Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Howard L. Martin Jr., Lawyer, Federal Aviation Administration Frank L. Cunningham, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration Thomas S. Westall, Former Official, Federal Aviation Administration C. Jonathan Tamplin, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration James E. McCoy Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration John R. Hallinan, Inspector, Federal Aviation Administration Paul Steucke, an Official, Federal Aviation Administration in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on June 24, 1994.
Use the citation No. 673031 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.
Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Side-by-side with Westlaw and LexisNexis

Feature FlawFinder Westlaw LexisNexis
Monthly price$19 – $99$133 – $646$153 – $399
ContractNone1–3 year min1–6 year min
Hidden fees$0, alwaysUp to $469/search$25/mo + per-doc
FlawCheck citatorIncludedKeyCite ($$$)Shepard's ($$$)
Plain-English summaryIncludedNoNo
CancelOne clickTermination feesAccount friction
Related Cases

Full legal research for $19/month

All 50 states · Federal regulations · Case law · Police SOPs · AI analysis included · No contract

Continue Researching →