Question 1

What did the Ninth Circuit decide in Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington?

Accepted Answer

Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.

Question 2

Is Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington still good law?

Accepted Answer

FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington in the current circuit citation data.

Question 3

When was Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington decided?

Accepted Answer

This case was decided on August 24, 1999.

Question 4

How do I cite Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington?

Accepted Answer

Use the citation No. 765836 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.

Feature	FlawFinder	Westlaw	LexisNexis
Monthly price	$19 – $99	$133 – $646	$153 – $399
Contract	None	1–3 year min	1–6 year min
Hidden fees	$0, always	Up to $469/search	$25/mo + per-doc
FlawCheck citator	Included	KeyCite ($$$)	Shepard's ($$$)
Plain-English summary	Included	No	No
Cancel	One click	Termination fees	Account friction

Gary Collins, Dennis Doyle Gary Ghirarduzzi Bruce Hamner Don Matthews Jeff McLaughlin Dave Phay v. David Lobdell, Personally and His Official Capacity as Assistant Fire Chief, and Spokane Valley Fire Protection District No. 1, a Public Employer and Political Subdivision of the State of Washington

Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Full legal research for $19/month