FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 780152
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Eleanor Staton Beverly Trotter Kevin Biglow, Solomon Williams Shirley Miller Deborah Woods Wendy Kelly Myron Knight Michael Eckles Donald Ballard William Bell, Clarence Thompson Doreen Ferguson Cynthia Evans Willie Wilson Mary Dean Brian Todd Tim Jones David Brawley Mara Ferrari Rhonda Capps Charles Jones David Roberts Verlene Maholmes Terry Fisher Carol Calender Evalean Moore Ralph Wilson Ronnie Mitchell Theodeshia Knauls Michael Marion, Nadine McClam Carla Abraham Bertha Alexander Shirley Allen Billynda E. Anderson Lawrence Andrews Dorothy J. Ayers Avis M. Banks Jimmie L. Banks Joyce A. Bates Ray A. Bates Ida M. Battles Marshall Battles, Sr. Terri M. Bean Alfred Beasley Vivian Jean Bell Marcia L. Benford Rosie J. Black Adrienne Bland Theresa Bozeman Byron Breckenridge John Bridgewater MacEo E. Bridgewater Annie Brooks Johnnie Paul Brooks Ronnie Brown Simon Brown, Jr. Mark A. Bufford William Bumpers Wilbert G. Burgess, Sr. Henry F. Butler Soloman C. Butts Ellis Cameron Harry Carlis Tevis Carpenter Ford Carr Tamu Chandler Betty Childers Michael Childers Ronald Clarke Melchester Clemons Gunice Colvin Kent Copridge Paul L. Coston, Jr. Debra F Coulter Cephas L. Curtis Angela C. Cravens James Crump Pauline Crump Tracy Cunningham Gilbert O. Dace Clarence Dancer Charles Daniels Patricia Davis Sam Davis Charles L. Davison Helen Marie Dean Evonne W. Dogan James E. Donaldson Tonia Dowell Alice Dunbar Allen Dunbar Throma Ann Dyas Terry Edwards Belinda Ellis Bezley Ellison Joseph Elmore Abiodun Fanimokun Sharon Fantroy Archie Fields Hicks Frank Sherline Franklin Allen W. Frazier Moses E. Greasham Freddie L. Grisby Kevin C. Guice Roderick W. Guice Roy E. Hall Charles H. Harden Dennis Harris Dorothy Harris Leon Harris Robert L. Harris Wylo Harvey Rosemarie W. Hauck Eric D. Hayden Fredrick Hightower, Jr. Charles H. Hill Larry Hollins Theodore Holt Delores Hood Kay M. Horton Verna J. Houston Phillip Bruce Hutchins Hattie L. Irving Della M. Jamison Johnnie L. Jefferson Reginald P. Jenkins Constance Johnson Darla Johnson Herbert G. Johnson James Johnson Kenneth Johnson Sharon E. Johnson Lecester Jones Phyllis J. Jones Brooks S. Kimbrough Claudette Lawson Doris Lenox Lynn B. Leufroy Walter G. Lewellen Frederick Lipsey Herbert E. Logan, Jr. Virginia G. Logan Presley T. Lorance Anthony L. Lucas Waymond MacOne Selicia Mallory Mark D. Matthews Rainard C. Mayhew Larry D. McIntosh Alberto A. McMiller Helen D. Medcafe Geraldine Moore Tennie Moore Wade Moore, Jr. Stephen R. Mundine Katherine Neal Arthur Newton Jacqueline Osborne Linda M. Ouids Ericka L. Owens Lee E. Owens, Jr. Leroy Parker C. Eugene Paschal Sandra L. Payne Stacy Payne Margaret Peach Robert J. Pearson Douglas Pegues Herman L. Poole Isaac M. Porter, Jr. Rhonda Randle James Ranson, Sr. Etha Reagans Rance H. Reed, Jr. Tressa Reed Brenda J. Richardson Cynthia Ridge Bettie Ridley Melvin L. Ridley Jackie Robinson Robert L. Robinson II Les L. Rogers Fred Roseborough T.D. Sanders Donna N. Scott Huey L. Scott Vince E. Seymore Maury J. Shaw William L. Sims David E. Singleton David Skillman Cleo P. Smith John Smith, Jr. Lucretia Smith David A. Stallworth Michael Stevens Octauia Stevens Carl Stovall Joyce Sullivan Idella Teague Alphonso E. Thompson Anthony Thompson Donna Thompson John F. Thompson Tywanna F. Thompson W.R. Thompson Benjamin F. Tillman David Tillman Shomide Tokunbo Anita Truitt Michael Turner Alan Ladd Tyson Rachel Frazier-Vann James L. Walker Aaron Washington Cecil R. Washington Eric C. Waters Charles E. Webb Shannon J. Weldon Rozell Wheaton Leonardo R. White Ernest M. Whitaker Bobby L. Williams Darryl Williams Daryl D. Williams Glen D. Williams, Sr. Kenneth Wayne Williams Lorry Williams Sylvester Williams, II Wilbert Williams Patricia Wilson Alfred M. Woods Martha Ybarra Jacquelyn L. Zeigler v. Boeing Company, and Boeing North American, Inc., a Delaware Corp McDonnell Douglas Corporation, a Maryland Corporation

No. 780152 · Decided November 26, 2002
No. 780152 · Ninth Circuit · 2002 · FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
November 26, 2002
Citation
No. 780152
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
Frequently Asked Questions
Eleanor Staton Beverly Trotter Kevin Biglow, Solomon Williams Shirley Miller Deborah Woods Wendy Kelly Myron Knight Michael Eckles Donald Ballard William Bell, Clarence Thompson Doreen Ferguson Cynthia Evans Willie Wilson Mary Dean Brian Todd Tim Jones David Brawley Mara Ferrari Rhonda Capps Charles Jones David Roberts Verlene Maholmes Terry Fisher Carol Calender Evalean Moore Ralph Wilson Ronnie Mitchell Theodeshia Knauls Michael Marion, Nadine McClam Carla Abraham Bertha Alexander Shirley Allen Billynda E. Anderson Lawrence Andrews Dorothy J. Ayers Avis M. Banks Jimmie L. Banks Joyce A. Bates Ray A. Bates Ida M. Battles Marshall Battles, Sr. Terri M. Bean Alfred Beasley Vivian Jean Bell Marcia L. Benford Rosie J. Black Adrienne Bland Theresa Bozeman Byron Breckenridge John Bridgewater MacEo E. Bridgewater Annie Brooks Johnnie Paul Brooks Ronnie Brown Simon Brown, Jr. Mark A. Bufford William Bumpers Wilbert G. Burgess, Sr. Henry F. Butler Soloman C. Butts Ellis Cameron Harry Carlis Tevis Carpenter Ford Carr Tamu Chandler Betty Childers Michael Childers Ronald Clarke Melchester Clemons Gunice Colvin Kent Copridge Paul L. Coston, Jr. Debra F Coulter Cephas L. Curtis Angela C. Cravens James Crump Pauline Crump Tracy Cunningham Gilbert O. Dace Clarence Dancer Charles Daniels Patricia Davis Sam Davis Charles L. Davison Helen Marie Dean Evonne W. Dogan James E. Donaldson Tonia Dowell Alice Dunbar Allen Dunbar Throma Ann Dyas Terry Edwards Belinda Ellis Bezley Ellison Joseph Elmore Abiodun Fanimokun Sharon Fantroy Archie Fields Hicks Frank Sherline Franklin Allen W. Frazier Moses E. Greasham Freddie L. Grisby Kevin C. Guice Roderick W. Guice Roy E. Hall Charles H. Harden Dennis Harris Dorothy Harris Leon Harris Robert L. Harris Wylo Harvey Rosemarie W. Hauck Eric D. Hayden Fredrick Hightower, Jr. Charles H. Hill Larry Hollins Theodore Holt Delores Hood Kay M. Horton Verna J. Houston Phillip Bruce Hutchins Hattie L. Irving Della M. Jamison Johnnie L. Jefferson Reginald P. Jenkins Constance Johnson Darla Johnson Herbert G. Johnson James Johnson Kenneth Johnson Sharon E. Johnson Lecester Jones Phyllis J. Jones Brooks S. Kimbrough Claudette Lawson Doris Lenox Lynn B. Leufroy Walter G. Lewellen Frederick Lipsey Herbert E. Logan, Jr. Virginia G. Logan Presley T. Lorance Anthony L. Lucas Waymond MacOne Selicia Mallory Mark D. Matthews Rainard C. Mayhew Larry D. McIntosh Alberto A. McMiller Helen D. Medcafe Geraldine Moore Tennie Moore Wade Moore, Jr. Stephen R. Mundine Katherine Neal Arthur Newton Jacqueline Osborne Linda M. Ouids Ericka L. Owens Lee E. Owens, Jr. Leroy Parker C. Eugene Paschal Sandra L. Payne Stacy Payne Margaret Peach Robert J. Pearson Douglas Pegues Herman L. Poole Isaac M. Porter, Jr. Rhonda Randle James Ranson, Sr. Etha Reagans Rance H. Reed, Jr. Tressa Reed Brenda J. Richardson Cynthia Ridge Bettie Ridley Melvin L. Ridley Jackie Robinson Robert L. Robinson II Les L. Rogers Fred Roseborough T.D. Sanders Donna N. Scott Huey L. Scott Vince E. Seymore Maury J. Shaw William L. Sims David E. Singleton David Skillman Cleo P. Smith John Smith, Jr. Lucretia Smith David A. Stallworth Michael Stevens Octauia Stevens Carl Stovall Joyce Sullivan Idella Teague Alphonso E. Thompson Anthony Thompson Donna Thompson John F. Thompson Tywanna F. Thompson W.R. Thompson Benjamin F. Tillman David Tillman Shomide Tokunbo Anita Truitt Michael Turner Alan Ladd Tyson Rachel Frazier-Vann James L. Walker Aaron Washington Cecil R. Washington Eric C. Waters Charles E. Webb Shannon J. Weldon Rozell Wheaton Leonardo R. White Ernest M. Whitaker Bobby L. Williams Darryl Williams Daryl D. Williams Glen D. Williams, Sr. Kenneth Wayne Williams Lorry Williams Sylvester Williams, II Wilbert Williams Patricia Wilson Alfred M. Woods Martha Ybarra Jacquelyn L. Zeigler v. Boeing Company, and Boeing North American, Inc., a Delaware Corp McDonnell Douglas Corporation, a Maryland Corporation is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Eleanor Staton Beverly Trotter Kevin Biglow, Solomon Williams Shirley Miller Deborah Woods Wendy Kelly Myron Knight Michael Eckles Donald Ballard William Bell, Clarence Thompson Doreen Ferguson Cynthia Evans Willie Wilson Mary Dean Brian Todd Tim Jones David Brawley Mara Ferrari Rhonda Capps Charles Jones David Roberts Verlene Maholmes Terry Fisher Carol Calender Evalean Moore Ralph Wilson Ronnie Mitchell Theodeshia Knauls Michael Marion, Nadine McClam Carla Abraham Bertha Alexander Shirley Allen Billynda E. Anderson Lawrence Andrews Dorothy J. Ayers Avis M. Banks Jimmie L. Banks Joyce A. Bates Ray A. Bates Ida M. Battles Marshall Battles, Sr. Terri M. Bean Alfred Beasley Vivian Jean Bell Marcia L. Benford Rosie J. Black Adrienne Bland Theresa Bozeman Byron Breckenridge John Bridgewater MacEo E. Bridgewater Annie Brooks Johnnie Paul Brooks Ronnie Brown Simon Brown, Jr. Mark A. Bufford William Bumpers Wilbert G. Burgess, Sr. Henry F. Butler Soloman C. Butts Ellis Cameron Harry Carlis Tevis Carpenter Ford Carr Tamu Chandler Betty Childers Michael Childers Ronald Clarke Melchester Clemons Gunice Colvin Kent Copridge Paul L. Coston, Jr. Debra F Coulter Cephas L. Curtis Angela C. Cravens James Crump Pauline Crump Tracy Cunningham Gilbert O. Dace Clarence Dancer Charles Daniels Patricia Davis Sam Davis Charles L. Davison Helen Marie Dean Evonne W. Dogan James E. Donaldson Tonia Dowell Alice Dunbar Allen Dunbar Throma Ann Dyas Terry Edwards Belinda Ellis Bezley Ellison Joseph Elmore Abiodun Fanimokun Sharon Fantroy Archie Fields Hicks Frank Sherline Franklin Allen W. Frazier Moses E. Greasham Freddie L. Grisby Kevin C. Guice Roderick W. Guice Roy E. Hall Charles H. Harden Dennis Harris Dorothy Harris Leon Harris Robert L. Harris Wylo Harvey Rosemarie W. Hauck Eric D. Hayden Fredrick Hightower, Jr. Charles H. Hill Larry Hollins Theodore Holt Delores Hood Kay M. Horton Verna J. Houston Phillip Bruce Hutchins Hattie L. Irving Della M. Jamison Johnnie L. Jefferson Reginald P. Jenkins Constance Johnson Darla Johnson Herbert G. Johnson James Johnson Kenneth Johnson Sharon E. Johnson Lecester Jones Phyllis J. Jones Brooks S. Kimbrough Claudette Lawson Doris Lenox Lynn B. Leufroy Walter G. Lewellen Frederick Lipsey Herbert E. Logan, Jr. Virginia G. Logan Presley T. Lorance Anthony L. Lucas Waymond MacOne Selicia Mallory Mark D. Matthews Rainard C. Mayhew Larry D. McIntosh Alberto A. McMiller Helen D. Medcafe Geraldine Moore Tennie Moore Wade Moore, Jr. Stephen R. Mundine Katherine Neal Arthur Newton Jacqueline Osborne Linda M. Ouids Ericka L. Owens Lee E. Owens, Jr. Leroy Parker C. Eugene Paschal Sandra L. Payne Stacy Payne Margaret Peach Robert J. Pearson Douglas Pegues Herman L. Poole Isaac M. Porter, Jr. Rhonda Randle James Ranson, Sr. Etha Reagans Rance H. Reed, Jr. Tressa Reed Brenda J. Richardson Cynthia Ridge Bettie Ridley Melvin L. Ridley Jackie Robinson Robert L. Robinson II Les L. Rogers Fred Roseborough T.D. Sanders Donna N. Scott Huey L. Scott Vince E. Seymore Maury J. Shaw William L. Sims David E. Singleton David Skillman Cleo P. Smith John Smith, Jr. Lucretia Smith David A. Stallworth Michael Stevens Octauia Stevens Carl Stovall Joyce Sullivan Idella Teague Alphonso E. Thompson Anthony Thompson Donna Thompson John F. Thompson Tywanna F. Thompson W.R. Thompson Benjamin F. Tillman David Tillman Shomide Tokunbo Anita Truitt Michael Turner Alan Ladd Tyson Rachel Frazier-Vann James L. Walker Aaron Washington Cecil R. Washington Eric C. Waters Charles E. Webb Shannon J. Weldon Rozell Wheaton Leonardo R. White Ernest M. Whitaker Bobby L. Williams Darryl Williams Daryl D. Williams Glen D. Williams, Sr. Kenneth Wayne Williams Lorry Williams Sylvester Williams, II Wilbert Williams Patricia Wilson Alfred M. Woods Martha Ybarra Jacquelyn L. Zeigler v. Boeing Company, and Boeing North American, Inc., a Delaware Corp McDonnell Douglas Corporation, a Maryland Corporation in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on November 26, 2002.
Use the citation No. 780152 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.
Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Why Attorneys Choose FlawFinder

Side-by-side with Westlaw and LexisNexis

Feature FlawFinder Westlaw LexisNexis
Monthly price$19 – $99$133 – $646$153 – $399
ContractNone1–3 year min1–6 year min
Hidden fees$0, alwaysUp to $469/search$25/mo + per-doc
FlawCheck citatorIncludedKeyCite ($$$)Shepard's ($$$)
Plain-English summaryIncludedNoNo
CancelOne clickTermination feesAccount friction
Related Cases

Full legal research for $19/month

All 50 states · Federal regulations · Case law · Police SOPs · AI analysis included · No contract

Continue Researching →