Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/Compania Mexicana De Aviacion, S.A., a Corporation Doing Business as Mexicana Airlines v. United States District Court for the Central District of California, and Adela Espinosa De Penasco, Carlos Penasco Garcia, Patricia Guadarrama Ortiz, Rodolfo Guadarrama Ortiz, Raul Guadaramma Ortiz, Ana Maria Esperanza Cuellar Marovilla, Federico Perez Munoz Lido, Amelia Neyra Perez, Pablo Eduardo Zuniga Escobar, Maria De Los Angeles Escobar Rodriguez, Rafael Mujica Bustos, Maria Luisa Susana Alarcon Mujica, Miguelangel Avila Rosales, Hector Avila Rosales, Rene Avila Rosales, Salvador Hernandez Amezcua, Maria Del Socorro Garcia Vizcaino, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Fernando Contreras Garcia and Liliana Contreras Garcia, Maria Teresa Alvarado Melgoza, Juan Rodriguez Guillen, Martha Rodriguez Guillen, Celia Rodriguez Guillen, Sylvia Rosaura Rodriguez Guillen, Rafael Palacios Ibarra, Enrique Rodriguez Guillen, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Cristobal Rodriguez Guillen and Pedro Rodriguez Guillen, Sophie Latrilleux, Fernando Gerardo, Michel Jimenez, Fernando Nicolas, Michel Vega, Rafaela Jimenez Michel, Leopoldo Raigoza Ortiz, Ana Luisa Sosa Ortiz, Alvaro Sosa Ortiz, Alfonso Sosa Ortiz, Arturo Sosa Ortiz, Alejandro Sosa Ortiz, Sergio Luis Velasco Ortiz, Rosa Leticia Velasco Ortiz, Martha Maria Velasco Ortiz, Lilia Rosa Velasco Ortiz, Alma Rosa Velasco Ortiz Carmen Fernandez Paredes, Luis Felipe Puente Bermudez, Carmen Espinosa Puente, Luis Felipe Puente Espinosa, Jose Haracio Robles Ramirez, Arturo Robles Casillas, Maria Asuncion Ramirez Robles, Maria Velasquez Rojas, Francisco Javier Velasquez Rojas, Jose Luis Velasquez Rojas, Sara Zaldivar Perez, Daniel Zaldivar Perez, Taide Zaldivar Perez, Ezperanza Zaldivar Perez, Enrique Zaldivar Perez, Guillermo Zaldivar Perez, Jaime Guzman Vasquez, Alicia Flores Guzman, Nelly Camacho Iniguez Ramirez, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Juan Joshua Ramirez Camacho, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Rogelio Domenge Morua, Aida Munoz Domenge, Lucero Celeste Banda Rueda, Leonidas Alejandro Banda Rueda, Faustino Garcia Espinosa, Maria Beceril Garcia, Rafael Pardo Grantison, Maria Magdalena Estrada, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Ricardo Enterria Diaz, Soledad Rivera Herrera, Jose Socorro Rivera, Jose Maria Guara, Laura Romero, Real Parties in Interest
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 513236
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Compania Mexicana De Aviacion, S.A., a Corporation Doing Business as Mexicana Airlines v. United States District Court for the Central District of California, and Adela Espinosa De Penasco, Carlos Penasco Garcia, Patricia Guadarrama Ortiz, Rodolfo Guadarrama Ortiz, Raul Guadaramma Ortiz, Ana Maria Esperanza Cuellar Marovilla, Federico Perez Munoz Lido, Amelia Neyra Perez, Pablo Eduardo Zuniga Escobar, Maria De Los Angeles Escobar Rodriguez, Rafael Mujica Bustos, Maria Luisa Susana Alarcon Mujica, Miguelangel Avila Rosales, Hector Avila Rosales, Rene Avila Rosales, Salvador Hernandez Amezcua, Maria Del Socorro Garcia Vizcaino, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Fernando Contreras Garcia and Liliana Contreras Garcia, Maria Teresa Alvarado Melgoza, Juan Rodriguez Guillen, Martha Rodriguez Guillen, Celia Rodriguez Guillen, Sylvia Rosaura Rodriguez Guillen, Rafael Palacios Ibarra, Enrique Rodriguez Guillen, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Cristobal Rodriguez Guillen and Pedro Rodriguez Guillen, Sophie Latrilleux, Fernando Gerardo, Michel Jimenez, Fernando Nicolas, Michel Vega, Rafaela Jimenez Michel, Leopoldo Raigoza Ortiz, Ana Luisa Sosa Ortiz, Alvaro Sosa Ortiz, Alfonso Sosa Ortiz, Arturo Sosa Ortiz, Alejandro Sosa Ortiz, Sergio Luis Velasco Ortiz, Rosa Leticia Velasco Ortiz, Martha Maria Velasco Ortiz, Lilia Rosa Velasco Ortiz, Alma Rosa Velasco Ortiz Carmen Fernandez Paredes, Luis Felipe Puente Bermudez, Carmen Espinosa Puente, Luis Felipe Puente Espinosa, Jose Haracio Robles Ramirez, Arturo Robles Casillas, Maria Asuncion Ramirez Robles, Maria Velasquez Rojas, Francisco Javier Velasquez Rojas, Jose Luis Velasquez Rojas, Sara Zaldivar Perez, Daniel Zaldivar Perez, Taide Zaldivar Perez, Ezperanza Zaldivar Perez, Enrique Zaldivar Perez, Guillermo Zaldivar Perez, Jaime Guzman Vasquez, Alicia Flores Guzman, Nelly Camacho Iniguez Ramirez, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Juan Joshua Ramirez Camacho, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Rogelio Domenge Morua, Aida Munoz Domenge, Lucero Celeste Banda Rueda, Leonidas Alejandro Banda Rueda, Faustino Garcia Espinosa, Maria Beceril Garcia, Rafael Pardo Grantison, Maria Magdalena Estrada, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Ricardo Enterria Diaz, Soledad Rivera Herrera, Jose Socorro Rivera, Jose Maria Guara, Laura Romero, Real Parties in Interest
No. 513236 · Decided October 17, 1988
No. 513236·Ninth Circuit · 1988·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
October 17, 1988
Citation
No. 513236
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Compania Mexicana De Aviacion, S.A., a Corporation Doing Business as Mexicana Airlines v. United States District Court for the Central District of California, and Adela Espinosa De Penasco, Carlos Penasco Garcia, Patricia Guadarrama Ortiz, Rodolfo Guadarrama Ortiz, Raul Guadaramma Ortiz, Ana Maria Esperanza Cuellar Marovilla, Federico Perez Munoz Lido, Amelia Neyra Perez, Pablo Eduardo Zuniga Escobar, Maria De Los Angeles Escobar Rodriguez, Rafael Mujica Bustos, Maria Luisa Susana Alarcon Mujica, Miguelangel Avila Rosales, Hector Avila Rosales, Rene Avila Rosales, Salvador Hernandez Amezcua, Maria Del Socorro Garcia Vizcaino, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Fernando Contreras Garcia and Liliana Contreras Garcia, Maria Teresa Alvarado Melgoza, Juan Rodriguez Guillen, Martha Rodriguez Guillen, Celia Rodriguez Guillen, Sylvia Rosaura Rodriguez Guillen, Rafael Palacios Ibarra, Enrique Rodriguez Guillen, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Cristobal Rodriguez Guillen and Pedro Rodriguez Guillen, Sophie Latrilleux, Fernando Gerardo, Michel Jimenez, Fernando Nicolas, Michel Vega, Rafaela Jimenez Michel, Leopoldo Raigoza Ortiz, Ana Luisa Sosa Ortiz, Alvaro Sosa Ortiz, Alfonso Sosa Ortiz, Arturo Sosa Ortiz, Alejandro Sosa Ortiz, Sergio Luis Velasco Ortiz, Rosa Leticia Velasco Ortiz, Martha Maria Velasco Ortiz, Lilia Rosa Velasco Ortiz, Alma Rosa Velasco Ortiz Carmen Fernandez Paredes, Luis Felipe Puente Bermudez, Carmen Espinosa Puente, Luis Felipe Puente Espinosa, Jose Haracio Robles Ramirez, Arturo Robles Casillas, Maria Asuncion Ramirez Robles, Maria Velasquez Rojas, Francisco Javier Velasquez Rojas, Jose Luis Velasquez Rojas, Sara Zaldivar Perez, Daniel Zaldivar Perez, Taide Zaldivar Perez, Ezperanza Zaldivar Perez, Enrique Zaldivar Perez, Guillermo Zaldivar Perez, Jaime Guzman Vasquez, Alicia Flores Guzman, Nelly Camacho Iniguez Ramirez, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Juan Joshua Ramirez Camacho, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Rogelio Domenge Morua, Aida Munoz Domenge, Lucero Celeste Banda Rueda, Leonidas Alejandro Banda Rueda, Faustino Garcia Espinosa, Maria Beceril Garcia, Rafael Pardo Grantison, Maria Magdalena Estrada, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Ricardo Enterria Diaz, Soledad Rivera Herrera, Jose Socorro Rivera, Jose Maria Guara, Laura Romero, Real Parties in Interest is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Compania Mexicana De Aviacion, S.A., a Corporation Doing Business as Mexicana Airlines v. United States District Court for the Central District of California, and Adela Espinosa De Penasco, Carlos Penasco Garcia, Patricia Guadarrama Ortiz, Rodolfo Guadarrama Ortiz, Raul Guadaramma Ortiz, Ana Maria Esperanza Cuellar Marovilla, Federico Perez Munoz Lido, Amelia Neyra Perez, Pablo Eduardo Zuniga Escobar, Maria De Los Angeles Escobar Rodriguez, Rafael Mujica Bustos, Maria Luisa Susana Alarcon Mujica, Miguelangel Avila Rosales, Hector Avila Rosales, Rene Avila Rosales, Salvador Hernandez Amezcua, Maria Del Socorro Garcia Vizcaino, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Fernando Contreras Garcia and Liliana Contreras Garcia, Maria Teresa Alvarado Melgoza, Juan Rodriguez Guillen, Martha Rodriguez Guillen, Celia Rodriguez Guillen, Sylvia Rosaura Rodriguez Guillen, Rafael Palacios Ibarra, Enrique Rodriguez Guillen, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Cristobal Rodriguez Guillen and Pedro Rodriguez Guillen, Sophie Latrilleux, Fernando Gerardo, Michel Jimenez, Fernando Nicolas, Michel Vega, Rafaela Jimenez Michel, Leopoldo Raigoza Ortiz, Ana Luisa Sosa Ortiz, Alvaro Sosa Ortiz, Alfonso Sosa Ortiz, Arturo Sosa Ortiz, Alejandro Sosa Ortiz, Sergio Luis Velasco Ortiz, Rosa Leticia Velasco Ortiz, Martha Maria Velasco Ortiz, Lilia Rosa Velasco Ortiz, Alma Rosa Velasco Ortiz Carmen Fernandez Paredes, Luis Felipe Puente Bermudez, Carmen Espinosa Puente, Luis Felipe Puente Espinosa, Jose Haracio Robles Ramirez, Arturo Robles Casillas, Maria Asuncion Ramirez Robles, Maria Velasquez Rojas, Francisco Javier Velasquez Rojas, Jose Luis Velasquez Rojas, Sara Zaldivar Perez, Daniel Zaldivar Perez, Taide Zaldivar Perez, Ezperanza Zaldivar Perez, Enrique Zaldivar Perez, Guillermo Zaldivar Perez, Jaime Guzman Vasquez, Alicia Flores Guzman, Nelly Camacho Iniguez Ramirez, Individually and as Guardian Ad Litem of Minors, Juan Joshua Ramirez Camacho, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Rogelio Domenge Morua, Aida Munoz Domenge, Lucero Celeste Banda Rueda, Leonidas Alejandro Banda Rueda, Faustino Garcia Espinosa, Maria Beceril Garcia, Rafael Pardo Grantison, Maria Magdalena Estrada, Javier Martinez Pacheco, Virginia Tocaven Henriquez, Ricardo Enterria Diaz, Soledad Rivera Herrera, Jose Socorro Rivera, Jose Maria Guara, Laura Romero, Real Parties in Interest in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on October 17, 1988.
Use the citation No. 513236 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.