Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/Charles Adams Josephine Sotro Daniel Abelein Susan Abelein William E. Allen Lars Andres Gurbaksh Singh Henry Andrew Gurmit Singh Karla Andrew Joe Sotro, Sr. Robert Andrews Joe Sotro, Jr Carol Andrews Cynthia Sotro Curt D. Barnes Roy Barnes Richard Steele Antoinette Barnes Wanda Steele Wilbur Steen Ernest Bartak Laura Steen Ann Bartak James Stroud Clarence Beardsley Mary Stroud Janice Beardsley Jerry Bergamyer Silas Suits Nadine Bergamyer Bette Suits Robert Bergevin Catherine Tharin Grace Bergevin Larry Thompson Donald Berry Judy Thompson Robert Tulp Claudette Tulp Gary Blackburn Daniel Vash Margaret Blackburn Eugene Botkins Carla Vash Dale Warner Gordon Bradberry Margaret Warner Linda Bradberry Richard Wenborne David Britton Noreen Wenborne Judy Britton Mike Williams Kenneth Brown Sheryl Williams Elizabeth Brown Gene R. Wolford Kenneth Buehner Dan Wyatt John Bufis Darlene Wyatt Penny Bufis Bruce Bulger Dorene Bulger Charles Byrd Jackie Byrd Robert Capehart Ingrid Capehart Roger Carter Lora Carter Roger Catlow Mary Catlow Boyd Chisholm Anita Chisholm Donald Clayton Yvonne Clayton Richard Collan Jacob Conner Barbara Conner Scott J. Conner Tom Costello Mary Costello Michael Dale Ellen Dale Thomas Emerson Lydia Emerson Helen Foy Marvin Franklin Barbara Franklin Gordon Freeman Ilene Freeman Joseph Gilmore Alan Gott Linda Gott James K. Hall Gary Hamm Mary Hamm James Harper Gilbert Hay, III Kenneth Herman David Higdon Sena Higdon Keith Hodnett William Holzendorf Barbara Holzendorf Brent Hubbard Dorinda Hubbard John Ittner Eleanor Ittner Robert Jenkins Eyonne Jenkins Bobbie Johnson Martha Johnson Timothy Kaczocha Kim Holmes Michael Keller Jin Keller Neal Kempt Karen Kemp James Lindley Ann Lindely Travis Lindley Barbara Lindley Marcus Lowe Susan Lowe Dan Lynch Florence Lynch Alfred Malinowski Walter Marlatt Audrey Marlatt Glenn Matherne Merril Matherne Gary McDonough Edwin McGifford Verna McGifford Thomas McIntyre Deborah McIntyre Fred McNatt Patricia McNatt Gerald McNeely Deborah McNeely John Mekulsia Roger Meier Karren Meier James Moffett Frances Moffett John B. Moody Glenn Mortensen Helen Nash Curt Nelson Lawrence Noble Mary Noble Gary Parker Larry Pauly Dale Pemberton Irene Pemberton Mike Ponder Debbie Ponder Larry Potts Shirley Potts Daniel Quinones A. Don Ray Bernice Ray Jay Schndieder Leon Shepard Mary Shepard Ron Shiplet Louetta Shiplet Judith Parker v. Norman S. Johnson Brad Lyle William McDevitt John Meek Daniel Mulhall David Osgrod Jill Page Wes Pohl Harry Potter Deborah Richie Robert Spooner Lavonne Tobia Marilyn Ulbright Candice Mack Larry Lindelof Thomas Ballard Teresa Castro, Deceased on 10/3/01 Chris Coones Colleen Haddigan John Hall Thomas Healy Walter J. Hoyt, III Sue Hullen Blake Johnson
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 784849
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Charles Adams Josephine Sotro Daniel Abelein Susan Abelein William E. Allen Lars Andres Gurbaksh Singh Henry Andrew Gurmit Singh Karla Andrew Joe Sotro, Sr. Robert Andrews Joe Sotro, Jr Carol Andrews Cynthia Sotro Curt D. Barnes Roy Barnes Richard Steele Antoinette Barnes Wanda Steele Wilbur Steen Ernest Bartak Laura Steen Ann Bartak James Stroud Clarence Beardsley Mary Stroud Janice Beardsley Jerry Bergamyer Silas Suits Nadine Bergamyer Bette Suits Robert Bergevin Catherine Tharin Grace Bergevin Larry Thompson Donald Berry Judy Thompson Robert Tulp Claudette Tulp Gary Blackburn Daniel Vash Margaret Blackburn Eugene Botkins Carla Vash Dale Warner Gordon Bradberry Margaret Warner Linda Bradberry Richard Wenborne David Britton Noreen Wenborne Judy Britton Mike Williams Kenneth Brown Sheryl Williams Elizabeth Brown Gene R. Wolford Kenneth Buehner Dan Wyatt John Bufis Darlene Wyatt Penny Bufis Bruce Bulger Dorene Bulger Charles Byrd Jackie Byrd Robert Capehart Ingrid Capehart Roger Carter Lora Carter Roger Catlow Mary Catlow Boyd Chisholm Anita Chisholm Donald Clayton Yvonne Clayton Richard Collan Jacob Conner Barbara Conner Scott J. Conner Tom Costello Mary Costello Michael Dale Ellen Dale Thomas Emerson Lydia Emerson Helen Foy Marvin Franklin Barbara Franklin Gordon Freeman Ilene Freeman Joseph Gilmore Alan Gott Linda Gott James K. Hall Gary Hamm Mary Hamm James Harper Gilbert Hay, III Kenneth Herman David Higdon Sena Higdon Keith Hodnett William Holzendorf Barbara Holzendorf Brent Hubbard Dorinda Hubbard John Ittner Eleanor Ittner Robert Jenkins Eyonne Jenkins Bobbie Johnson Martha Johnson Timothy Kaczocha Kim Holmes Michael Keller Jin Keller Neal Kempt Karen Kemp James Lindley Ann Lindely Travis Lindley Barbara Lindley Marcus Lowe Susan Lowe Dan Lynch Florence Lynch Alfred Malinowski Walter Marlatt Audrey Marlatt Glenn Matherne Merril Matherne Gary McDonough Edwin McGifford Verna McGifford Thomas McIntyre Deborah McIntyre Fred McNatt Patricia McNatt Gerald McNeely Deborah McNeely John Mekulsia Roger Meier Karren Meier James Moffett Frances Moffett John B. Moody Glenn Mortensen Helen Nash Curt Nelson Lawrence Noble Mary Noble Gary Parker Larry Pauly Dale Pemberton Irene Pemberton Mike Ponder Debbie Ponder Larry Potts Shirley Potts Daniel Quinones A. Don Ray Bernice Ray Jay Schndieder Leon Shepard Mary Shepard Ron Shiplet Louetta Shiplet Judith Parker v. Norman S. Johnson Brad Lyle William McDevitt John Meek Daniel Mulhall David Osgrod Jill Page Wes Pohl Harry Potter Deborah Richie Robert Spooner Lavonne Tobia Marilyn Ulbright Candice Mack Larry Lindelof Thomas Ballard Teresa Castro, Deceased on 10/3/01 Chris Coones Colleen Haddigan John Hall Thomas Healy Walter J. Hoyt, III Sue Hullen Blake Johnson
No. 784849 · Decided January 22, 2004
No. 784849·Ninth Circuit · 2004·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
January 22, 2004
Citation
No. 784849
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Charles Adams Josephine Sotro Daniel Abelein Susan Abelein William E. Allen Lars Andres Gurbaksh Singh Henry Andrew Gurmit Singh Karla Andrew Joe Sotro, Sr. Robert Andrews Joe Sotro, Jr Carol Andrews Cynthia Sotro Curt D. Barnes Roy Barnes Richard Steele Antoinette Barnes Wanda Steele Wilbur Steen Ernest Bartak Laura Steen Ann Bartak James Stroud Clarence Beardsley Mary Stroud Janice Beardsley Jerry Bergamyer Silas Suits Nadine Bergamyer Bette Suits Robert Bergevin Catherine Tharin Grace Bergevin Larry Thompson Donald Berry Judy Thompson Robert Tulp Claudette Tulp Gary Blackburn Daniel Vash Margaret Blackburn Eugene Botkins Carla Vash Dale Warner Gordon Bradberry Margaret Warner Linda Bradberry Richard Wenborne David Britton Noreen Wenborne Judy Britton Mike Williams Kenneth Brown Sheryl Williams Elizabeth Brown Gene R. Wolford Kenneth Buehner Dan Wyatt John Bufis Darlene Wyatt Penny Bufis Bruce Bulger Dorene Bulger Charles Byrd Jackie Byrd Robert Capehart Ingrid Capehart Roger Carter Lora Carter Roger Catlow Mary Catlow Boyd Chisholm Anita Chisholm Donald Clayton Yvonne Clayton Richard Collan Jacob Conner Barbara Conner Scott J. Conner Tom Costello Mary Costello Michael Dale Ellen Dale Thomas Emerson Lydia Emerson Helen Foy Marvin Franklin Barbara Franklin Gordon Freeman Ilene Freeman Joseph Gilmore Alan Gott Linda Gott James K. Hall Gary Hamm Mary Hamm James Harper Gilbert Hay, III Kenneth Herman David Higdon Sena Higdon Keith Hodnett William Holzendorf Barbara Holzendorf Brent Hubbard Dorinda Hubbard John Ittner Eleanor Ittner Robert Jenkins Eyonne Jenkins Bobbie Johnson Martha Johnson Timothy Kaczocha Kim Holmes Michael Keller Jin Keller Neal Kempt Karen Kemp James Lindley Ann Lindely Travis Lindley Barbara Lindley Marcus Lowe Susan Lowe Dan Lynch Florence Lynch Alfred Malinowski Walter Marlatt Audrey Marlatt Glenn Matherne Merril Matherne Gary McDonough Edwin McGifford Verna McGifford Thomas McIntyre Deborah McIntyre Fred McNatt Patricia McNatt Gerald McNeely Deborah McNeely John Mekulsia Roger Meier Karren Meier James Moffett Frances Moffett John B. Moody Glenn Mortensen Helen Nash Curt Nelson Lawrence Noble Mary Noble Gary Parker Larry Pauly Dale Pemberton Irene Pemberton Mike Ponder Debbie Ponder Larry Potts Shirley Potts Daniel Quinones A. Don Ray Bernice Ray Jay Schndieder Leon Shepard Mary Shepard Ron Shiplet Louetta Shiplet Judith Parker v. Norman S. Johnson Brad Lyle William McDevitt John Meek Daniel Mulhall David Osgrod Jill Page Wes Pohl Harry Potter Deborah Richie Robert Spooner Lavonne Tobia Marilyn Ulbright Candice Mack Larry Lindelof Thomas Ballard Teresa Castro, Deceased on 10/3/01 Chris Coones Colleen Haddigan John Hall Thomas Healy Walter J. Hoyt, III Sue Hullen Blake Johnson is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Charles Adams Josephine Sotro Daniel Abelein Susan Abelein William E. Allen Lars Andres Gurbaksh Singh Henry Andrew Gurmit Singh Karla Andrew Joe Sotro, Sr. Robert Andrews Joe Sotro, Jr Carol Andrews Cynthia Sotro Curt D. Barnes Roy Barnes Richard Steele Antoinette Barnes Wanda Steele Wilbur Steen Ernest Bartak Laura Steen Ann Bartak James Stroud Clarence Beardsley Mary Stroud Janice Beardsley Jerry Bergamyer Silas Suits Nadine Bergamyer Bette Suits Robert Bergevin Catherine Tharin Grace Bergevin Larry Thompson Donald Berry Judy Thompson Robert Tulp Claudette Tulp Gary Blackburn Daniel Vash Margaret Blackburn Eugene Botkins Carla Vash Dale Warner Gordon Bradberry Margaret Warner Linda Bradberry Richard Wenborne David Britton Noreen Wenborne Judy Britton Mike Williams Kenneth Brown Sheryl Williams Elizabeth Brown Gene R. Wolford Kenneth Buehner Dan Wyatt John Bufis Darlene Wyatt Penny Bufis Bruce Bulger Dorene Bulger Charles Byrd Jackie Byrd Robert Capehart Ingrid Capehart Roger Carter Lora Carter Roger Catlow Mary Catlow Boyd Chisholm Anita Chisholm Donald Clayton Yvonne Clayton Richard Collan Jacob Conner Barbara Conner Scott J. Conner Tom Costello Mary Costello Michael Dale Ellen Dale Thomas Emerson Lydia Emerson Helen Foy Marvin Franklin Barbara Franklin Gordon Freeman Ilene Freeman Joseph Gilmore Alan Gott Linda Gott James K. Hall Gary Hamm Mary Hamm James Harper Gilbert Hay, III Kenneth Herman David Higdon Sena Higdon Keith Hodnett William Holzendorf Barbara Holzendorf Brent Hubbard Dorinda Hubbard John Ittner Eleanor Ittner Robert Jenkins Eyonne Jenkins Bobbie Johnson Martha Johnson Timothy Kaczocha Kim Holmes Michael Keller Jin Keller Neal Kempt Karen Kemp James Lindley Ann Lindely Travis Lindley Barbara Lindley Marcus Lowe Susan Lowe Dan Lynch Florence Lynch Alfred Malinowski Walter Marlatt Audrey Marlatt Glenn Matherne Merril Matherne Gary McDonough Edwin McGifford Verna McGifford Thomas McIntyre Deborah McIntyre Fred McNatt Patricia McNatt Gerald McNeely Deborah McNeely John Mekulsia Roger Meier Karren Meier James Moffett Frances Moffett John B. Moody Glenn Mortensen Helen Nash Curt Nelson Lawrence Noble Mary Noble Gary Parker Larry Pauly Dale Pemberton Irene Pemberton Mike Ponder Debbie Ponder Larry Potts Shirley Potts Daniel Quinones A. Don Ray Bernice Ray Jay Schndieder Leon Shepard Mary Shepard Ron Shiplet Louetta Shiplet Judith Parker v. Norman S. Johnson Brad Lyle William McDevitt John Meek Daniel Mulhall David Osgrod Jill Page Wes Pohl Harry Potter Deborah Richie Robert Spooner Lavonne Tobia Marilyn Ulbright Candice Mack Larry Lindelof Thomas Ballard Teresa Castro, Deceased on 10/3/01 Chris Coones Colleen Haddigan John Hall Thomas Healy Walter J. Hoyt, III Sue Hullen Blake Johnson in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on January 22, 2004.
Use the citation No. 784849 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.