Home/Case Law/Ninth Circuit/American States Insurance Company v. Alexis Borbor, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jose Borbor Jose Borbor Carmen Santiago Hannah Chen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Benjamin Chen Benjamin Chen Ruth Chen Jenelle Mullen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Judith Mullen Judith Mullen Aaron Taylor, by His Guardian Ad Litem Cynthia Taylor Cynthia Taylor Dionn Walker, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Rita Walker Rita Walker Amy Aulenta, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Frank Aulenta Leslie Aulenta Kimberly Deal, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Linda Deal Linda Deal Rocky Deal Amber Lee Thompson, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Bruce Thompson Bruce Thompson Marcele Teschler Tara Vallee, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Donna Vallee Donna Vallee Steven Vallee Michelle Lautarevsky, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Carroll Lautarevsky Carroll Lautarevsky Alexander Lautarevsky Jason Herrera Yvonne Herrera Rudy Herrera Dina Jones and Victor Jones, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Victor Jones Victor Jones Dely Jones Ronald Walker Mellissa Gary Jiminez, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Javier Jiminez Javier Jiminez Christine Jiminez Misha Suksnguan, by Her Guardian Ad Litem L. Suksnguan L. Suksnguan Winai Suksnguan Carl and Paul Fessler, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Janet Fessler Doug Fessler Liza Betancourt, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jock Betancourt Jock Betancourt Elizabeth Betancourt Anthony Langford by His Guardian Ad Litem Wiley Langford Wiley Langford Michele Langford Erica Kochner, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Ralph Kochner Ralph Kochner Dianna Kochner Robbie Hernandez, by His Guardian Ad Litem Sherry Hernandez Sherry Hernandez Rain and Joshua Jacobs, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Darryl Jacobs Darryl Jacobs Diane Jacobs E. James Meacham and E. James Meacham and S. Isabel Meacham, Dba Isabel's Nursery School
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 492740
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
American States Insurance Company v. Alexis Borbor, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jose Borbor Jose Borbor Carmen Santiago Hannah Chen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Benjamin Chen Benjamin Chen Ruth Chen Jenelle Mullen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Judith Mullen Judith Mullen Aaron Taylor, by His Guardian Ad Litem Cynthia Taylor Cynthia Taylor Dionn Walker, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Rita Walker Rita Walker Amy Aulenta, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Frank Aulenta Leslie Aulenta Kimberly Deal, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Linda Deal Linda Deal Rocky Deal Amber Lee Thompson, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Bruce Thompson Bruce Thompson Marcele Teschler Tara Vallee, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Donna Vallee Donna Vallee Steven Vallee Michelle Lautarevsky, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Carroll Lautarevsky Carroll Lautarevsky Alexander Lautarevsky Jason Herrera Yvonne Herrera Rudy Herrera Dina Jones and Victor Jones, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Victor Jones Victor Jones Dely Jones Ronald Walker Mellissa Gary Jiminez, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Javier Jiminez Javier Jiminez Christine Jiminez Misha Suksnguan, by Her Guardian Ad Litem L. Suksnguan L. Suksnguan Winai Suksnguan Carl and Paul Fessler, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Janet Fessler Doug Fessler Liza Betancourt, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jock Betancourt Jock Betancourt Elizabeth Betancourt Anthony Langford by His Guardian Ad Litem Wiley Langford Wiley Langford Michele Langford Erica Kochner, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Ralph Kochner Ralph Kochner Dianna Kochner Robbie Hernandez, by His Guardian Ad Litem Sherry Hernandez Sherry Hernandez Rain and Joshua Jacobs, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Darryl Jacobs Darryl Jacobs Diane Jacobs E. James Meacham and E. James Meacham and S. Isabel Meacham, Dba Isabel's Nursery School
No. 492740 · Decided October 22, 1987
No. 492740·Ninth Circuit · 1987·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Decided
October 22, 1987
Citation
No. 492740
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
American States Insurance Company v. Alexis Borbor, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jose Borbor Jose Borbor Carmen Santiago Hannah Chen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Benjamin Chen Benjamin Chen Ruth Chen Jenelle Mullen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Judith Mullen Judith Mullen Aaron Taylor, by His Guardian Ad Litem Cynthia Taylor Cynthia Taylor Dionn Walker, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Rita Walker Rita Walker Amy Aulenta, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Frank Aulenta Leslie Aulenta Kimberly Deal, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Linda Deal Linda Deal Rocky Deal Amber Lee Thompson, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Bruce Thompson Bruce Thompson Marcele Teschler Tara Vallee, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Donna Vallee Donna Vallee Steven Vallee Michelle Lautarevsky, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Carroll Lautarevsky Carroll Lautarevsky Alexander Lautarevsky Jason Herrera Yvonne Herrera Rudy Herrera Dina Jones and Victor Jones, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Victor Jones Victor Jones Dely Jones Ronald Walker Mellissa Gary Jiminez, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Javier Jiminez Javier Jiminez Christine Jiminez Misha Suksnguan, by Her Guardian Ad Litem L. Suksnguan L. Suksnguan Winai Suksnguan Carl and Paul Fessler, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Janet Fessler Doug Fessler Liza Betancourt, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jock Betancourt Jock Betancourt Elizabeth Betancourt Anthony Langford by His Guardian Ad Litem Wiley Langford Wiley Langford Michele Langford Erica Kochner, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Ralph Kochner Ralph Kochner Dianna Kochner Robbie Hernandez, by His Guardian Ad Litem Sherry Hernandez Sherry Hernandez Rain and Joshua Jacobs, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Darryl Jacobs Darryl Jacobs Diane Jacobs E. James Meacham and E. James Meacham and S. Isabel Meacham, Dba Isabel's Nursery School is a decision of the Ninth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for American States Insurance Company v. Alexis Borbor, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jose Borbor Jose Borbor Carmen Santiago Hannah Chen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Benjamin Chen Benjamin Chen Ruth Chen Jenelle Mullen, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Judith Mullen Judith Mullen Aaron Taylor, by His Guardian Ad Litem Cynthia Taylor Cynthia Taylor Dionn Walker, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Rita Walker Rita Walker Amy Aulenta, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Frank Aulenta Leslie Aulenta Kimberly Deal, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Linda Deal Linda Deal Rocky Deal Amber Lee Thompson, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Bruce Thompson Bruce Thompson Marcele Teschler Tara Vallee, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Donna Vallee Donna Vallee Steven Vallee Michelle Lautarevsky, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Carroll Lautarevsky Carroll Lautarevsky Alexander Lautarevsky Jason Herrera Yvonne Herrera Rudy Herrera Dina Jones and Victor Jones, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Victor Jones Victor Jones Dely Jones Ronald Walker Mellissa Gary Jiminez, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Javier Jiminez Javier Jiminez Christine Jiminez Misha Suksnguan, by Her Guardian Ad Litem L. Suksnguan L. Suksnguan Winai Suksnguan Carl and Paul Fessler, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Janet Fessler Doug Fessler Liza Betancourt, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Jock Betancourt Jock Betancourt Elizabeth Betancourt Anthony Langford by His Guardian Ad Litem Wiley Langford Wiley Langford Michele Langford Erica Kochner, by Her Guardian Ad Litem Ralph Kochner Ralph Kochner Dianna Kochner Robbie Hernandez, by His Guardian Ad Litem Sherry Hernandez Sherry Hernandez Rain and Joshua Jacobs, by Their Guardian Ad Litem Darryl Jacobs Darryl Jacobs Diane Jacobs E. James Meacham and E. James Meacham and S. Isabel Meacham, Dba Isabel's Nursery School in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on October 22, 1987.
Use the citation No. 492740 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.