Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/Soughik Kayzakian, ('Sonia') v. Charles R. Buck, Sued in His Individual Capacity Former Secretary of Health Theodore Thornton, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Secretary, Department of Personnel Alp Karahasan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Acting Director, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Sandra Leichtman, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity Chief Phychologist, Mental Hygiene Administration Bruce L. Regan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director of Psychiatric Education and Training, Mental Hygiene Administration, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Springfield Hospital Center Thomas F. Krajewski, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Superintendent, Springfield Hospital Center Jonathan D. Book, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Clinical Director, Springfield Hospital Center Peter T. Pomilo, Sued in His Individual Capacity Irfan S. Esendal, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Martin Gross Unit, Springfield Hospital Center Reza G. Bassiri, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, City Division, Springfield Hospital Center Duesdedit Jolbitado, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Chair, Hospital Privileging Committee, Springfield Hospital Center Philip P. Townsend, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Personnel Administrator, Springfield Hospital Center Randy Roberts, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Phychological Services, Springfield Hospital Center Daniel R. Malone, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Staff Psychologist, Springfield Hospital Center Jae Park, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center Ethel Mattegunta, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 517086
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Soughik Kayzakian, ('Sonia') v. Charles R. Buck, Sued in His Individual Capacity Former Secretary of Health Theodore Thornton, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Secretary, Department of Personnel Alp Karahasan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Acting Director, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Sandra Leichtman, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity Chief Phychologist, Mental Hygiene Administration Bruce L. Regan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director of Psychiatric Education and Training, Mental Hygiene Administration, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Springfield Hospital Center Thomas F. Krajewski, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Superintendent, Springfield Hospital Center Jonathan D. Book, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Clinical Director, Springfield Hospital Center Peter T. Pomilo, Sued in His Individual Capacity Irfan S. Esendal, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Martin Gross Unit, Springfield Hospital Center Reza G. Bassiri, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, City Division, Springfield Hospital Center Duesdedit Jolbitado, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Chair, Hospital Privileging Committee, Springfield Hospital Center Philip P. Townsend, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Personnel Administrator, Springfield Hospital Center Randy Roberts, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Phychological Services, Springfield Hospital Center Daniel R. Malone, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Staff Psychologist, Springfield Hospital Center Jae Park, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center Ethel Mattegunta, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center
No. 517086 · Decided June 19, 1989
No. 517086·Fourth Circuit · 1989·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
June 19, 1989
Citation
No. 517086
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Soughik Kayzakian, ('Sonia') v. Charles R. Buck, Sued in His Individual Capacity Former Secretary of Health Theodore Thornton, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Secretary, Department of Personnel Alp Karahasan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Acting Director, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Sandra Leichtman, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity Chief Phychologist, Mental Hygiene Administration Bruce L. Regan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director of Psychiatric Education and Training, Mental Hygiene Administration, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Springfield Hospital Center Thomas F. Krajewski, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Superintendent, Springfield Hospital Center Jonathan D. Book, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Clinical Director, Springfield Hospital Center Peter T. Pomilo, Sued in His Individual Capacity Irfan S. Esendal, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Martin Gross Unit, Springfield Hospital Center Reza G. Bassiri, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, City Division, Springfield Hospital Center Duesdedit Jolbitado, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Chair, Hospital Privileging Committee, Springfield Hospital Center Philip P. Townsend, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Personnel Administrator, Springfield Hospital Center Randy Roberts, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Phychological Services, Springfield Hospital Center Daniel R. Malone, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Staff Psychologist, Springfield Hospital Center Jae Park, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center Ethel Mattegunta, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Soughik Kayzakian, ('Sonia') v. Charles R. Buck, Sued in His Individual Capacity Former Secretary of Health Theodore Thornton, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Secretary, Department of Personnel Alp Karahasan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Acting Director, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Sandra Leichtman, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity Chief Phychologist, Mental Hygiene Administration Bruce L. Regan, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director of Psychiatric Education and Training, Mental Hygiene Administration, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene Springfield Hospital Center Thomas F. Krajewski, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Superintendent, Springfield Hospital Center Jonathan D. Book, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Clinical Director, Springfield Hospital Center Peter T. Pomilo, Sued in His Individual Capacity Irfan S. Esendal, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Martin Gross Unit, Springfield Hospital Center Reza G. Bassiri, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, City Division, Springfield Hospital Center Duesdedit Jolbitado, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Chair, Hospital Privileging Committee, Springfield Hospital Center Philip P. Townsend, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Personnel Administrator, Springfield Hospital Center Randy Roberts, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Director, Phychological Services, Springfield Hospital Center Daniel R. Malone, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Staff Psychologist, Springfield Hospital Center Jae Park, Sued in His Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center Ethel Mattegunta, Sued in Her Individual as Well as Official Capacity, Physician, Springfield Hospital Center in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on June 19, 1989.
Use the citation No. 517086 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.