Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/Robert M. & Bettie H. Loving Dewey C. & Mary C. Martin Paul B. & Gertrude G. Lacy Ira Francis & Mamie Byer Cynthia S. Byer James H. & Virginia F. Burr Ray E. & Bianco Plasters Paul L. & Buna H. Pearman Jack D. & Mary F. Showalter Lonnie D. & Patricia S. Howard A.B. & Lucille M. Caul Ben C. & Norma B. Meeks Merrill S. & Lois D. Mays Robert J. & Lillian F. Smith Eugene C. & Hallie L. Dressler Donald J. & Cynthia L. Tincher William T. & Patricia L. Daily Adelaide D. Bowen Richard Glen & Susan B. Bailey William E. & Rosemary C. Driscoll Leonard E. & Sally A. Nicely, Jr. Rober B. & Judy D. Evans Charles D. & Joyce R. Deacon Homer F. & Faye A. Landis Grover H. & Virginia K. Byer Harold B. & Mary T. Dressler Raymond E. & Betty F. Oyler Dora McCaleb James P. & Mary C. Kern Elsie J. McCormick Paul B. Lacy, III Frank G. & Nellie Pearl Gooch J. Murray & Ellen T. Thompson Frank E. & Ethel v. Sponaugle, Sr. Thomas G. & Geraldine W. Botkins, Sr. Camp Appalachia Apensui Inc. And Citizen's United for River & Property Rights v. Clifford Alexander, Secretary, Dept. Of the Army Corps of Engineers Lt. Gen. John W. Morris Maj. Gen. James A. Johnson Col. Douglas L. Haller, Virginia Farm Bureau Federation, Amicus Curiae/As
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 442877
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Robert M. & Bettie H. Loving Dewey C. & Mary C. Martin Paul B. & Gertrude G. Lacy Ira Francis & Mamie Byer Cynthia S. Byer James H. & Virginia F. Burr Ray E. & Bianco Plasters Paul L. & Buna H. Pearman Jack D. & Mary F. Showalter Lonnie D. & Patricia S. Howard A.B. & Lucille M. Caul Ben C. & Norma B. Meeks Merrill S. & Lois D. Mays Robert J. & Lillian F. Smith Eugene C. & Hallie L. Dressler Donald J. & Cynthia L. Tincher William T. & Patricia L. Daily Adelaide D. Bowen Richard Glen & Susan B. Bailey William E. & Rosemary C. Driscoll Leonard E. & Sally A. Nicely, Jr. Rober B. & Judy D. Evans Charles D. & Joyce R. Deacon Homer F. & Faye A. Landis Grover H. & Virginia K. Byer Harold B. & Mary T. Dressler Raymond E. & Betty F. Oyler Dora McCaleb James P. & Mary C. Kern Elsie J. McCormick Paul B. Lacy, III Frank G. & Nellie Pearl Gooch J. Murray & Ellen T. Thompson Frank E. & Ethel v. Sponaugle, Sr. Thomas G. & Geraldine W. Botkins, Sr. Camp Appalachia Apensui Inc. And Citizen's United for River & Property Rights v. Clifford Alexander, Secretary, Dept. Of the Army Corps of Engineers Lt. Gen. John W. Morris Maj. Gen. James A. Johnson Col. Douglas L. Haller, Virginia Farm Bureau Federation, Amicus Curiae/As
No. 442877 · Decided October 4, 1984
No. 442877·Fourth Circuit · 1984·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
October 4, 1984
Citation
No. 442877
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Robert M. & Bettie H. Loving Dewey C. & Mary C. Martin Paul B. & Gertrude G. Lacy Ira Francis & Mamie Byer Cynthia S. Byer James H. & Virginia F. Burr Ray E. & Bianco Plasters Paul L. & Buna H. Pearman Jack D. & Mary F. Showalter Lonnie D. & Patricia S. Howard A.B. & Lucille M. Caul Ben C. & Norma B. Meeks Merrill S. & Lois D. Mays Robert J. & Lillian F. Smith Eugene C. & Hallie L. Dressler Donald J. & Cynthia L. Tincher William T. & Patricia L. Daily Adelaide D. Bowen Richard Glen & Susan B. Bailey William E. & Rosemary C. Driscoll Leonard E. & Sally A. Nicely, Jr. Rober B. & Judy D. Evans Charles D. & Joyce R. Deacon Homer F. & Faye A. Landis Grover H. & Virginia K. Byer Harold B. & Mary T. Dressler Raymond E. & Betty F. Oyler Dora McCaleb James P. & Mary C. Kern Elsie J. McCormick Paul B. Lacy, III Frank G. & Nellie Pearl Gooch J. Murray & Ellen T. Thompson Frank E. & Ethel v. Sponaugle, Sr. Thomas G. & Geraldine W. Botkins, Sr. Camp Appalachia Apensui Inc. And Citizen's United for River & Property Rights v. Clifford Alexander, Secretary, Dept. Of the Army Corps of Engineers Lt. Gen. John W. Morris Maj. Gen. James A. Johnson Col. Douglas L. Haller, Virginia Farm Bureau Federation, Amicus Curiae/As is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Robert M. & Bettie H. Loving Dewey C. & Mary C. Martin Paul B. & Gertrude G. Lacy Ira Francis & Mamie Byer Cynthia S. Byer James H. & Virginia F. Burr Ray E. & Bianco Plasters Paul L. & Buna H. Pearman Jack D. & Mary F. Showalter Lonnie D. & Patricia S. Howard A.B. & Lucille M. Caul Ben C. & Norma B. Meeks Merrill S. & Lois D. Mays Robert J. & Lillian F. Smith Eugene C. & Hallie L. Dressler Donald J. & Cynthia L. Tincher William T. & Patricia L. Daily Adelaide D. Bowen Richard Glen & Susan B. Bailey William E. & Rosemary C. Driscoll Leonard E. & Sally A. Nicely, Jr. Rober B. & Judy D. Evans Charles D. & Joyce R. Deacon Homer F. & Faye A. Landis Grover H. & Virginia K. Byer Harold B. & Mary T. Dressler Raymond E. & Betty F. Oyler Dora McCaleb James P. & Mary C. Kern Elsie J. McCormick Paul B. Lacy, III Frank G. & Nellie Pearl Gooch J. Murray & Ellen T. Thompson Frank E. & Ethel v. Sponaugle, Sr. Thomas G. & Geraldine W. Botkins, Sr. Camp Appalachia Apensui Inc. And Citizen's United for River & Property Rights v. Clifford Alexander, Secretary, Dept. Of the Army Corps of Engineers Lt. Gen. John W. Morris Maj. Gen. James A. Johnson Col. Douglas L. Haller, Virginia Farm Bureau Federation, Amicus Curiae/As in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on October 4, 1984.
Use the citation No. 442877 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.