Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue, Defendants- Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 696581
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue, Defendants- Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue
No. 696581 · Decided June 5, 1995
No. 696581·Fourth Circuit · 1995·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
June 5, 1995
Citation
No. 696581
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue, Defendants- Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue, Defendants- Norman W. Swanson William H. Talbert Robert B. Campbell Billy Clark Charles A. Dancy Wallace M. Davis William E. Denton Galena Elworth Melvin F. Eyerman Hamilton M. Howe Ralph P. Hunt Henry F. Murray William E. Nicholson, III Robert A. Nisbet John L. Powell, Jr. Donald v. Wallace Mary L. Pritchard Carl L. Whitney Ira N. Schwarz Grady L. Strange Walter J. Bartnikowski Marion B. Zollicoffer Browning Adams Pritchard C. Adams William H. Adams Edward H. Allen Flossie P. Allen Joseph A. Allen Rachel C. Allred Helen L. Anctil Leo I. Anctil Ronald E. Anderson Clarence P. Armstrong Carroll W. Austin F.L. Austin, Jr. Donald P. Bahr Paul Ballus Charles D. Barker, Sr. Walter E. Barkhouse Edward C. Barret James L. Baxter Russell W. Beard Bernard L. Beatty Richard K. Bell Leo E. Benade Sherman W. Betts Joseph H. Betz Robert L. Blevins Franklin M. Blunt Timothy C. Bolick Margaret C. Boone Henry A. Botkin Alex Bourdas Ola May Bovender, A/K/A Ola May Tate Eugene A. Bowen Lavaune K. Breda Marlowe G. Breda Trond G. Brekke Laura B. Brendle Millard Bridgers Clarence M. Bridges Doris K. Bridges Cyrus H. Brooks, Jr. Daniel R. Brown K.A. Brown William D. Brown Betty P. Bullock Robert S. Bullock Findley Burns, Jr. Ray G. Burrell Richard E. Bush James M. Byrne Norman L. Carlton Matthew E. Carmean Frank Cates J. Crawford Caton Harry E. Chamberlain Vincent H. Chase Paul F. Chavez Woodrow H. Childress John G. Church Herman L. Clanton Robert L. Clarke Charles C. Clausen, Sr. Dennis E. Cleckner Steve P. Clemenic Lacy W. Coates Rucia A. Cobb James A. Coddington Catheryn S. Coley Laura K. Conder James C. Conine Marshall G. Cooper Asbury Coward, III Newton P. Cox Ruth A. Cox Burnett E. Creasman Thomas J. Culkin Hazel B. Curlee Milton L. Dial Beatrice G. Davis Bernley S. Davis Donald M. Davis Essie M. Davis George E. Davis Robert J. Davis Clifford H. Dawson Calvin F. Dean Orien G. Dean, Jr. Jack M. Deaton Violet B. Deitmaring Arlen J. Devito John E. Devlyn Sara E. Devlyn Joy E. Dickinson Mrs. Leroy B. Dickinson James E. Diffee Delbert R. Dillion Margaret H. Dopf Raymond E. Dopf Leroy M. Duffy Charles F. Dupont Bobby R. Eason David Edmisten Carl F. Effler John H. Elder, Jr. John R. Ellis Manford G. Farr Rita Festo John J. Filan Angelo A. Florentino Robert W. Folden Oscar F. Fowler Melvin W. Fritz Walton E. Fulcher Robert C. Fuller Walter E. Fuller Frank W. Furches Norman Carl Gaddis Marshall L. Gaddy Thomas B. Gardiner Robert F. Geissler William E. Gentner, Jr. Thomas P. Ginn Robert W. Goodman John R. Gordon Bernice C. Grandy, Jr. Steven W. Grandy Robert J. Green Michael R. Greeson James H. Griffin Thomas M. Groome, Jr. James W. Gross Arthur S. Gunderson Hert L. Hancock, Jr. James M. Hardin C. Lee Harris Howard W. Harris Paul H. Harvey Roland R. Hatcher Henry S. Heffley, Jr. Carroll A. Hefner Clarence J. Hensley, Jr. Richard M. Heriot Doris T. Herring Novis S. Herring Virginia R. Hildebrand Mozelle L. Hinshaw Herman J. Hipps Rufus M. Hodgin Donald R. Hoffman Charles K. Hoffmeyer Mary R. Holland Edgar P. Holt Ray Homeslely Ned A. Hood Robert H. Hood Stephen W. Hopkins Clyde L. Howard, Jr. Kevin G. Hughes Harvey R. Hurst Sam P. Hyatt John L. Irby Mattie B. Ives Francis Jacobs Richard L. Jarrett Jacqueline M. Jennings Woodrow W. Jones Donald L. Jorgenson Kenneth R. Joseph Patsie W. Joseph Everette R. Keller Bernard J. Kelley Wilson P. Kemp Howard Lee Kerr Margaret C. Kerr William S. Ketner David L.G. King Thomas M. King, Jr. John E. Kirk Paul E. Kirkland, Sr. Evelyn W. Kinney Raymond B. Kleber George M. Knobl, Jr. William F. Knopf Max v. Krebbs William J. Kuhn, Jr. James M. Langston, Jr. Jan W. Langston Elmer L. Lashua John L. Latham Daniel M. Lauderback August R. Lawrence Frieda H. Lewis Norwood P. Lewis Henry G. Liles Dorothy J. Liles Walter E. Linthicum Phyllis v. Lippard George Lott Robert P. Lucas Allen M. Mabe Thomas S. MacEluch William F. Marcuson, Jr. Warner G. Maupin Lylton E. Maxwell Oliver A. Mays Samuel S. McCachren Elizabeth S. McCaskill Aileen S. McCraw Elizabeth G. McDonald Clyde W. McGirk Donald D. McGuire Norman H. McLaughlin Doy K. McPhail William Ray Medlin, Jr. Ernest E. Miller Margaret H. Miller Edgar N. Millington Harold J. Mitchiner Eugene E. Moody Dorothy C. Moore James C. Moore, Jr. Lucie Moorman Robert M. Moose Jack B. Morris Regena E. Morrison Stanley B. Morse Woodford T. Moseley George R. Muse R.J. Nettles Thomas G. Newport John E. Nitsche Alfred P. Norwood Johnnie M. Ochoa Elvin E. Oglesby Oliver G. Oja Russell E. Olson Lloyd A. Osborne Paul B. Osgood William C. Page Lee R. Paramore Lewis W. Pate Charles R. Patton Vernon J. Pebbles W.W. Pegues Mary E. Penn John D. Penn Elliotte T. Perkins, Jr. William H. Perry, Jr. Frank J. Piazza, Sr. Jesse G. Pickering, III Paul J. Phillippi Richard L. Phillips Ruby A. Phillips Dallas Pickard, Jr. George A. Pinter Edward W. Piper Frederick H. Pless R.F. Hoke Pollock Lewington S. Ponder Elbert Y. Poole Jennette C. Poole Martha Boyce Poteat Edwin H. Price Charles R. Pugh Daniel J. Quesenberry Milton H. Quinn Louise M. Rabbino Thomas M. Ramsey Jack G. Ray Marshall G. Ray Hazel S. Redmon George R. Reinhart, III Annie E. Renkel Madge O. Reynolds Franklin E. Richardson, Jr. Allen W. Rigsby George M. Roberts Jennings B. Robinson James P. Roth Phifer P. Rothman Harold E. Ruble Hilda H. Rultenberg Donald E. Russell George W. Sabo Lyle E. Samson Robert L. Scheer Frederick L. Schuermann, Sr. Robert J. Schullery Elwood M. Shaulis Robert T. Sheridan Stanley T. Shipley Charles B. Shiveley Charles A. Shue, Jr. Ruth M. Shue Elsie N. Simmons Frederick E. Simmons Mary B. Simpson Manuel F. Siverio Joseph A. Sizoo Evelyn S. Smith George B. Smith James A. Smith James E. Smith James P. Smith Joe F. Smith Percy H. Smith Joseph L. Sommer Ray H. Spangler James A. Sprankle Wiley L. Standifer, Jr. James W. Starbuck Gertrude D. Starling Stacy J. Starling Henry C. Steed, Jr. Roy C. Steeley Arthur L. Stewart Burlena J. Stewart John R. Stewart, Jr. George W. Stillway Rita M. Stillway Harold E. Stone Clyde Dalton Stowe Harry H. Strunk E.C. Stumpf Ellis G. Sumner Leo B. Sumner Mildred Y. Sumner Margaret K. Swink James E. Sykes Oliver B. Talbert James D. Terrell Clyde E. Thompson Emogene M. Thompson Fred L. Tracy Rocco H. Trombello John G. Truitt, Jr. William H. Turk James T. Vance Ethel D. Vanhorn Edward J. Vaughn Edward Venkler Roy L. Vick, Sr. Kermit J. Vinson Myrtle H. Vinson William E. Wade Floyd H. Waldrop Wanda E. Wallace Roland J. Weber Grace F. Weiner Lona C. Weisner Lawrence D. Welch Paul B. Welch, Jr. George L. Westerlind William B. White T.M. Whittington, Jr. George W. Wilkins Robert S. Williams, Jr. William C. Williams Winton H. Williams Harold P. Williamson Edna Mae Wilson Robert Graves Wilson, Jr. Ernest G. Winston Peter S. Wondolowski Robert v. Wood Maynard B. Woodbury Evelyn W. Woodbury Jack R. Worley John T. Worrell George T. Worrell George E. Yale, Jr. William P. Yarborough Charles L. Berry Robert D. Lennon Zebulon v. Moseley, III Gary W. O'Neal Milton S. Price Martin L. Dpeicher Paul H. Turney v. Janice H. Faulkner, Secretary of the North Carolina Department of Revenue Harlan E. Boyles, Treasurer of the State of North Carolina North Carolina Department of Revenue in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on June 5, 1995.
Use the citation No. 696581 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.