Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf Levendorf Insurance Agency, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates, and Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 707036
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf Levendorf Insurance Agency, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates, and Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center
No. 707036 · Decided October 25, 1995
No. 707036·Fourth Circuit · 1995·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
October 25, 1995
Citation
No. 707036
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf Levendorf Insurance Agency, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates, and Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. Marvin H. Levendorf Kelly Levendorf Levendorf Insurance Agency, and George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Lubin C. Alimario Robert Turner Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Alimario Medical Associates P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center, Jorge A. Martinez, M.D. v. George M. Roig, M.D. Leonard Z. Alpert, Esq. Lubin C. Alimario George M. Roig, M.D., Incorporated Alpert, D'AnnibAlle & Visnic Alimario Medical Associates, and Carl N. Frankovitch, Esq. Arthur M. Recht, Esq. Mark A. Colantonio, Esq. David L. Robertson, Esq. Robert Wettstein Marvin H. Levendorf Robert Turner Kelly Levendorf Gary Hanson Charles A. Okey Antonio Licata Reynaldo Vista Carlos Vasquez George Kosar Nasser Emami Steve Clarke Arthur L. Miser Donald R. Donell John W. Koval Mel Arena Robert Cattrell William S. Gallagher Amrik A. Chattha Gurdev Purewal Joseph Schreiber Junginder Luthra Addie Tamboli Jasbir Makar David Cross, Esq. Callie Tsapis Cynthia Santoro Gustke Forest Bowman Sherri D. Goodman Volk, Frankovitch, Anetakis, Recht, Robertson & Hellerstedt Weirton Medical Center, Incorporated Levendorf Insurance Agency P.I.E. Mutual Insurance Company Board of Trustees of the Weirton Medical Center Executive Committee of the Medical and Dental Staff of the Weirton Medical Center in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on October 25, 1995.
Use the citation No. 707036 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.