Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/John Lee Worsham, and Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Jeffrey Steven Kersey, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clarence Julius Chew, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Charles Hatfield John Lee Worsham, and Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Hercules Williams, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Joseph Colvin, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary Oof Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Marvin Williamson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Frederick Johnson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Anderson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Moore, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, David P. Brown, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 712499
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
John Lee Worsham, and Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Jeffrey Steven Kersey, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clarence Julius Chew, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Charles Hatfield John Lee Worsham, and Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Hercules Williams, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Joseph Colvin, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary Oof Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Marvin Williamson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Frederick Johnson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Anderson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Moore, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, David P. Brown, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner
No. 712499 · Decided January 31, 1996
No. 712499·Fourth Circuit · 1996·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
January 31, 1996
Citation
No. 712499
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
John Lee Worsham, and Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Jeffrey Steven Kersey, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clarence Julius Chew, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Charles Hatfield John Lee Worsham, and Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Hercules Williams, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Joseph Colvin, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary Oof Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Marvin Williamson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Frederick Johnson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Anderson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Moore, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, David P. Brown, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for John Lee Worsham, and Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Jeffrey Steven Kersey, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clarence Julius Chew, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. Richard A. Lanham, and William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Wallace Ward Jeffrey Steven Kersey Charles Hatfield John Lee Worsham, and Clarence Julius Chew Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Hercules Williams, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Joseph Colvin, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary Oof Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Marvin Williamson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Frederick Johnson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Anderson, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, Clifton Moore, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner, David P. Brown, and John Lee Worsham Wallace Ward Clarence Julius Chew Jeffrey Steven Kersey Joseph B. Smith Donald L. Knox Charles Hatfield Dorothy Stevenson Karen Fried Liston Noble Anthony Edward Henderson Clifford Hinds-Bey Jonny Brown Percy Smith, and All Others Similarly Situated v. William D. Schaeffer Bishop L. Robinson, Secretary of Public Safety and Correctional Services Richard A. Lanham Division of Corrections Marvin N. Robbins, Executive Director, Igo Melanie C. Pereira, Deputy Commissioner Mary Anne Saar, Former Acting Secretary Paul Davis, Chairman Marjorie A. Jennings, Commissioner Frank Pappas, Commissioner Patricia K. Cushwa, Commissioner MacEo Williams, Commissioner Dan Zaccagnini, Commissioner Michael C. Blount, Commissioner in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on January 31, 1996.
Use the citation No. 712499 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.