Home/Case Law/Fourth Circuit/Fred Basham Sylvia Basham, His Wife James Eugene Bowling Betty Jo Bowling, His Wife Woodrow Wilson Brogan, Jr. Theresa Brogan, His Wife Dennis L. Cook Eva Cook, His Wife Brice Jean Crook Connie Crook, His Wife David Lucas Frances Lucas, His Wife Gene Miller Doris Miller, His Wife Rocky Nelson Sue Nelson, His Wife Ronnie Nelson Tamara Nelson, His Wife Emory A. Richmond Donna Richmond, His Wife Alfred L. Faulkner Peggy W. Faulkner, His Wife Batteries, Incorporated, a Corporation Norman Crook Patricia Crook, His Wife John Daniel Helen Daniel, His Wife Luther Green Frances Green, His Wife Hobert Honaker Louise Honaker, His Wife Glen Hunt Nancy Hunt, His Wife Edward Liu Karman Liu, His Wife Joseph A. Maiolo Florence Sandra Maiolo, His Wife Roger Mitchem Judy Mitchem, His Wife Walter W. Setliff Shelby Jean Setliff, His Wife Lacy Darel Shrewsbury Delores Edith Shrewsbury, His Wife Paul Zutaut Rebecca Zutaut, His Wife Roger Dale Bragg Jo Ellen Bragg, His Wife William Lee Brash Willie Sue Brash, His Wife Estil Price Brooks Lorita Mae Brooks, His Wife Richard L. Smith Christine Smith, His Wife Deskar L. Brogan Clorine Brogan, His Wife David Wayne Brown Paul Burrell Ruby Burrell, His Wife Richard E. Daniels Ernest L. French Elsie Jane French, His Wife James R. Fox, Jr. Sallie Ann Fox, His Wife Eugene A. Hicks, Sr. Sue Ann Hicks, His Wife Danny Mansfield Ola R. Mansfield, His Wife Robert Eugene Martin Wanda Kay Martin, His Wife Enoch McKinney Helen Louise McKinney His Wife Bessie Richmond Chester Tankersley Nadell Tankersley, His Wife Robert Underwood Roger Wimmer Carmen Wimmer, His Wife William Donald Wise, Sr. Mary Ann Wise, His Wife Dolphis R. Wood Carol S. Wood, His Wife Lena Conte v. General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So, Robert Bolen, Jean Verletta Bolen, Husband and Wife Thomas C. Martin Clyde D. Ratcliffe, Beverly Ratcliffe, Hsuband and Wife George Buchanan, Edna Buchanan, Husband and Wife David G. Perry, Nancy R. Perry, Husband and Wife William E. Painter, Myra Painter, Husband and Wife Jim Sarver, Janie Sarver, Husband and Wife Anna Mae Lyons, Robert W. Lyons, Husband and Wife Robert W. Edwards, Linda Edwards, Husband and Wife Lesley Vest, Bonita Vest, Husband and Wife John Sylvester, Ava Sylvester, Husband and Wife William A. Moore, Nancy Moore, Husband and Wife, Plaintiffs-Appellant,vsv. W General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So
FlawCheck Citator
Check how courts have cited this case. Use our free citator for the most current treatment.
No. 603069
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Fred Basham Sylvia Basham, His Wife James Eugene Bowling Betty Jo Bowling, His Wife Woodrow Wilson Brogan, Jr. Theresa Brogan, His Wife Dennis L. Cook Eva Cook, His Wife Brice Jean Crook Connie Crook, His Wife David Lucas Frances Lucas, His Wife Gene Miller Doris Miller, His Wife Rocky Nelson Sue Nelson, His Wife Ronnie Nelson Tamara Nelson, His Wife Emory A. Richmond Donna Richmond, His Wife Alfred L. Faulkner Peggy W. Faulkner, His Wife Batteries, Incorporated, a Corporation Norman Crook Patricia Crook, His Wife John Daniel Helen Daniel, His Wife Luther Green Frances Green, His Wife Hobert Honaker Louise Honaker, His Wife Glen Hunt Nancy Hunt, His Wife Edward Liu Karman Liu, His Wife Joseph A. Maiolo Florence Sandra Maiolo, His Wife Roger Mitchem Judy Mitchem, His Wife Walter W. Setliff Shelby Jean Setliff, His Wife Lacy Darel Shrewsbury Delores Edith Shrewsbury, His Wife Paul Zutaut Rebecca Zutaut, His Wife Roger Dale Bragg Jo Ellen Bragg, His Wife William Lee Brash Willie Sue Brash, His Wife Estil Price Brooks Lorita Mae Brooks, His Wife Richard L. Smith Christine Smith, His Wife Deskar L. Brogan Clorine Brogan, His Wife David Wayne Brown Paul Burrell Ruby Burrell, His Wife Richard E. Daniels Ernest L. French Elsie Jane French, His Wife James R. Fox, Jr. Sallie Ann Fox, His Wife Eugene A. Hicks, Sr. Sue Ann Hicks, His Wife Danny Mansfield Ola R. Mansfield, His Wife Robert Eugene Martin Wanda Kay Martin, His Wife Enoch McKinney Helen Louise McKinney His Wife Bessie Richmond Chester Tankersley Nadell Tankersley, His Wife Robert Underwood Roger Wimmer Carmen Wimmer, His Wife William Donald Wise, Sr. Mary Ann Wise, His Wife Dolphis R. Wood Carol S. Wood, His Wife Lena Conte v. General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So, Robert Bolen, Jean Verletta Bolen, Husband and Wife Thomas C. Martin Clyde D. Ratcliffe, Beverly Ratcliffe, Hsuband and Wife George Buchanan, Edna Buchanan, Husband and Wife David G. Perry, Nancy R. Perry, Husband and Wife William E. Painter, Myra Painter, Husband and Wife Jim Sarver, Janie Sarver, Husband and Wife Anna Mae Lyons, Robert W. Lyons, Husband and Wife Robert W. Edwards, Linda Edwards, Husband and Wife Lesley Vest, Bonita Vest, Husband and Wife John Sylvester, Ava Sylvester, Husband and Wife William A. Moore, Nancy Moore, Husband and Wife, Plaintiffs-Appellant,vsv. W General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So
No. 603069 · Decided March 10, 1993
No. 603069·Fourth Circuit · 1993·
FlawFinder last updated this page Apr. 2, 2026
Case Details
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Decided
March 10, 1993
Citation
No. 603069
Disposition
See opinion text.
Full Opinion
Plain English Summary
Plain-English summary coming soon. Read the opinion text below for the current holding.
Key Points
01
02
03
04
Frequently Asked Questions
Fred Basham Sylvia Basham, His Wife James Eugene Bowling Betty Jo Bowling, His Wife Woodrow Wilson Brogan, Jr. Theresa Brogan, His Wife Dennis L. Cook Eva Cook, His Wife Brice Jean Crook Connie Crook, His Wife David Lucas Frances Lucas, His Wife Gene Miller Doris Miller, His Wife Rocky Nelson Sue Nelson, His Wife Ronnie Nelson Tamara Nelson, His Wife Emory A. Richmond Donna Richmond, His Wife Alfred L. Faulkner Peggy W. Faulkner, His Wife Batteries, Incorporated, a Corporation Norman Crook Patricia Crook, His Wife John Daniel Helen Daniel, His Wife Luther Green Frances Green, His Wife Hobert Honaker Louise Honaker, His Wife Glen Hunt Nancy Hunt, His Wife Edward Liu Karman Liu, His Wife Joseph A. Maiolo Florence Sandra Maiolo, His Wife Roger Mitchem Judy Mitchem, His Wife Walter W. Setliff Shelby Jean Setliff, His Wife Lacy Darel Shrewsbury Delores Edith Shrewsbury, His Wife Paul Zutaut Rebecca Zutaut, His Wife Roger Dale Bragg Jo Ellen Bragg, His Wife William Lee Brash Willie Sue Brash, His Wife Estil Price Brooks Lorita Mae Brooks, His Wife Richard L. Smith Christine Smith, His Wife Deskar L. Brogan Clorine Brogan, His Wife David Wayne Brown Paul Burrell Ruby Burrell, His Wife Richard E. Daniels Ernest L. French Elsie Jane French, His Wife James R. Fox, Jr. Sallie Ann Fox, His Wife Eugene A. Hicks, Sr. Sue Ann Hicks, His Wife Danny Mansfield Ola R. Mansfield, His Wife Robert Eugene Martin Wanda Kay Martin, His Wife Enoch McKinney Helen Louise McKinney His Wife Bessie Richmond Chester Tankersley Nadell Tankersley, His Wife Robert Underwood Roger Wimmer Carmen Wimmer, His Wife William Donald Wise, Sr. Mary Ann Wise, His Wife Dolphis R. Wood Carol S. Wood, His Wife Lena Conte v. General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So, Robert Bolen, Jean Verletta Bolen, Husband and Wife Thomas C. Martin Clyde D. Ratcliffe, Beverly Ratcliffe, Hsuband and Wife George Buchanan, Edna Buchanan, Husband and Wife David G. Perry, Nancy R. Perry, Husband and Wife William E. Painter, Myra Painter, Husband and Wife Jim Sarver, Janie Sarver, Husband and Wife Anna Mae Lyons, Robert W. Lyons, Husband and Wife Robert W. Edwards, Linda Edwards, Husband and Wife Lesley Vest, Bonita Vest, Husband and Wife John Sylvester, Ava Sylvester, Husband and Wife William A. Moore, Nancy Moore, Husband and Wife, Plaintiffs-Appellant,vsv. W General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So is a decision of the Fourth Circuit. Review the opinion text below for the holding.
FlawCheck shows no negative treatment for Fred Basham Sylvia Basham, His Wife James Eugene Bowling Betty Jo Bowling, His Wife Woodrow Wilson Brogan, Jr. Theresa Brogan, His Wife Dennis L. Cook Eva Cook, His Wife Brice Jean Crook Connie Crook, His Wife David Lucas Frances Lucas, His Wife Gene Miller Doris Miller, His Wife Rocky Nelson Sue Nelson, His Wife Ronnie Nelson Tamara Nelson, His Wife Emory A. Richmond Donna Richmond, His Wife Alfred L. Faulkner Peggy W. Faulkner, His Wife Batteries, Incorporated, a Corporation Norman Crook Patricia Crook, His Wife John Daniel Helen Daniel, His Wife Luther Green Frances Green, His Wife Hobert Honaker Louise Honaker, His Wife Glen Hunt Nancy Hunt, His Wife Edward Liu Karman Liu, His Wife Joseph A. Maiolo Florence Sandra Maiolo, His Wife Roger Mitchem Judy Mitchem, His Wife Walter W. Setliff Shelby Jean Setliff, His Wife Lacy Darel Shrewsbury Delores Edith Shrewsbury, His Wife Paul Zutaut Rebecca Zutaut, His Wife Roger Dale Bragg Jo Ellen Bragg, His Wife William Lee Brash Willie Sue Brash, His Wife Estil Price Brooks Lorita Mae Brooks, His Wife Richard L. Smith Christine Smith, His Wife Deskar L. Brogan Clorine Brogan, His Wife David Wayne Brown Paul Burrell Ruby Burrell, His Wife Richard E. Daniels Ernest L. French Elsie Jane French, His Wife James R. Fox, Jr. Sallie Ann Fox, His Wife Eugene A. Hicks, Sr. Sue Ann Hicks, His Wife Danny Mansfield Ola R. Mansfield, His Wife Robert Eugene Martin Wanda Kay Martin, His Wife Enoch McKinney Helen Louise McKinney His Wife Bessie Richmond Chester Tankersley Nadell Tankersley, His Wife Robert Underwood Roger Wimmer Carmen Wimmer, His Wife William Donald Wise, Sr. Mary Ann Wise, His Wife Dolphis R. Wood Carol S. Wood, His Wife Lena Conte v. General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So, Robert Bolen, Jean Verletta Bolen, Husband and Wife Thomas C. Martin Clyde D. Ratcliffe, Beverly Ratcliffe, Hsuband and Wife George Buchanan, Edna Buchanan, Husband and Wife David G. Perry, Nancy R. Perry, Husband and Wife William E. Painter, Myra Painter, Husband and Wife Jim Sarver, Janie Sarver, Husband and Wife Anna Mae Lyons, Robert W. Lyons, Husband and Wife Robert W. Edwards, Linda Edwards, Husband and Wife Lesley Vest, Bonita Vest, Husband and Wife John Sylvester, Ava Sylvester, Husband and Wife William A. Moore, Nancy Moore, Husband and Wife, Plaintiffs-Appellant,vsv. W General Shale Products Corporation, a Corporation Which May or May Not Be Licensed to Do Business Within the State of West Virginia but Which is Doing So in the current circuit citation data.
This case was decided on March 10, 1993.
Use the citation No. 603069 and verify it against the official reporter before filing.